文献速递心血管USMR

左束支传导阻滞相关应变失同步的超声心动图评估:与标记磁共振成像的比较

Echocardiographic Assessment of Left Bundle Branch-Related Strain Dyssynchrony: A Comparison With Tagged MRI.
PubMed 文献 · Ultrasound Med Biol · 2019-05-03

研究在犬左束支传导阻滞诱导前后,比较斑点追踪超声心动图(STE)与标记磁共振成像(MRI-T)测得的环向应变,并评估正则化方法的影响。STE与MRI-T整体一致性良好,但STE高估收缩期应变,且不同软件与正则化方式所得室间隔应变模式和室间隔反弹拉伸存在差异。

要点

  • STE与MRI-T的标准化环向应变整体和区域一致性良好,但STE高估收缩期应变(偏差≥4%)。
  • 室间隔应变模式和室间隔反弹拉伸随STE软件及正则化方式变化,各STE方法在左束支传导阻滞前即测得非零室间隔反弹拉伸。
  • 作者认为在实现标准化前,需开放研究以理解STE方法间差异的原因。

核心结论

  • STE与MRI-T的标准化环向应变整体一致性良好,但STE高估收缩期应变;室间隔应变模式和室间隔反弹拉伸随软件及正则化方式变化,标准化前需开放研究理解STE方法间差异的原因。

研究设计与样本

  • 动物实验:犬左束支传导阻滞诱导前(n=8)与诱导后(n=9)行二维胸骨旁超声和MRI-T左心室短轴视图采集;超声应变分析在DICOM数据中段水平用三种整体方法(「商业软件」「基础块匹配」「正则化块匹配」)进行,并比较三种正则化方式;MRI-T用SinMod分析。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 标准化环向应变曲线基于标准六段或室间隔/侧壁段分析,并与MRI-T数据交叉相关。
  • 所有STE方法均显示收缩期应变估计偏高,偏差≥4%应变。
  • 左束支传导阻滞前,基础法(平均ρ=0.96)和正则化法(平均ρ=0.97)与MRI-T的室间隔和侧壁段相关性极好;商业法两壁间差异显著(室间隔ρ=0.94,侧壁ρ=0.68)。
  • 与MRI-T的相关性在左束支传导阻滞前后降低:商业法ρ=0.79,基础法ρ=0.82,平均正则化法ρ=0.86。
  • 室间隔应变模式和室间隔反弹拉伸随STE软件及正则化类型变化,所有STE方法在左束支传导阻滞前均估计出非零室间隔反弹拉伸值。

局限性

  • 作者指出,在实现标准化前,需开放研究以理解STE方法间差异的原因。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

Recent studies have shown the efficacy of myocardial strain estimated using speckle tracking echocardiography (STE) in predicting response to cardiac resynchronisation therapy. This study focuses on circumferential strain patterns, comparing STE-acquired strains to tagged-magnetic resonance imaging (MRI-T). Second, the effect of regularisation was examined. Two-dimensional parasternal ultrasound (US) and MRI-T data were acquired in the left ventricular short-axis view of canines before (n = 8) and after (n = 9) left bunch branch block (LBBB) induction. US-based strain analysis was performed on Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine data at the mid-level using three overall methods ("Commercial software," "Basic block-matching," "regularised block-matching"). Moreover, three regularisation approaches were implemented and compared. MRI-T analysis was performed using SinMod. Normalised regional circumferential strain curves, based on standard six or septal/lateral segments, were analysed and cross-correlated with MRI-T data. Systolic strain (SS) and septal rebound stretch (SRS) were calculated and compared. Overall agreement of normalised circumferential strain was good between all methods on a global and regional level. All STE methods showed a bias (≥4% strain) toward higher SS estimates. Pre-LBBB, septal and lateral segment correlation was excellent between the Basic (mean ρ = 0.96) and regularised (mean ρ = 0.97) methods and MRI-T. The Commercial method showed a significant discrepancy between the two walls (septal ρ = 0.94, lateral ρ = 0.68). Correlation with MRI-T reduced between pre- and post-LBBB (Commercial ρ = 0.79, Basic ρ = 0.82, mean regularised ρ = 0.86). Septal strain patterns and SRS varied with the STE software and type of regularisation, with all STE methods estimating non-zero SRS values pre-LBBB. Absolute values showed moderate agreement, with a bias for higher strain from STE. SRS varied with the type of software and extra regularisation applied. Open efforts are needed to understand the underlying causes of differences between STE methods before standardisation can be achieved. This is particularly important given the apparent clinical value of strain-based parameters such as SRS.

来源:Ultrasound Med Biol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Fixsen LS, de Lepper AGW, Strik M, et al. Echocardiographic Assessment of Left Bundle Branch-Related Strain Dyssynchrony: A Comparison With Tagged MRI. Ultrasound Med Biol. 2019. PMID: 31060858. doi:10.1016/j.ultrasmedbio.2019.03.012

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。