为什么先天性心脏缺陷会被漏诊?
该病例对照研究分析2015至2016年荷兰西北地区114例出生后孤立性严重先天性心脏缺陷(CHD)胎儿,其中58例(50.9%)产前筛查漏诊、56例(49.1%)检出;漏诊组心脏检查质量评分、放大使用率及各切面评分均显著低于检出组;操作者年筛查量与应用质量评分显著相关;漏诊原因包括适应技能不足致图像不佳、图像显示异常但未识别、图像质量好但表现正常。
要点
- 漏诊组心脏检查质量评分达标(≥12分)比例32% vs 检出组64%(P=0.002)。
- 漏诊组各切面评分均低于检出组:四腔心2.7 vs 3.9,三血管3.0 vs 3.8,左室流出道1.9 vs 3.3,右室流出道1.9 vs 3.3。
- 漏诊原因:49%因适应技能不足致图像不佳,31%图像显示异常未识别,20%图像质量好但表现正常。
核心结论
- 二维筛查中适应技能不足(而非BMI或胎儿体位等 circumstantial 因素)似乎是产前未检出CHD的重要原因;漏诊组心脏切面质量显著低于检出组;即便图像质量足够,仍有31%病例未被识别;操作者年筛查量高显著有助于产前检出;20%漏诊病例图像质量好但CHD不可见。
研究设计与样本
- 病例对照研究,从PRECOR登记库提取2015至2016年荷兰西北地区出生后孤立性严重CHD病例,严重CHD定义为出生后第一年需手术修复;共114例,其中92例有筛查图像;由两名胎儿超声心动图专家在不知CHD诊断及产前是否检出的情况下,对四腔心、三血管、左室流出道和右室流出道切面按0至5分评分;比较检出与漏诊组检查质量参数,并用回归分析评估操作者经验与筛查中心经验同质量评分的关联。
关键影像表现/征象
- 漏诊组心脏检查质量评分达标(≥12分)比例为32%,检出组为64%(P=0.002)。
- 漏诊组正确使用放大比例为58%,检出组为84%(P=0.01)。
- 漏诊组四腔心切面评分2.7,检出组3.9(P<0.001)。
- 漏诊组三血管切面评分3.0,检出组3.8(P=0.02)。
- 漏诊组左室流出道与右室流出道评分均为1.9,检出组均为3.3(P<0.001)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 严重CHD定义为出生后第一年需手术修复。
- 心脏检查总体质量评分≥12分定义为达标。
- 各心脏切面按0至5分评分技术正确性。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 筛查中应重视四腔心、三血管及左右室流出道切面的技术正确性,并正确使用放大。
- 49%漏诊因适应技能不足致图像不佳,31%因图像显示异常(主要为间隔缺损和主动脉弓异常)未在筛查时识别。
- 操作者年筛查量与心脏检查质量评分显著相关。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Congenital heart defects (CHD) are still missed frequently in prenatal screening programs, which can result in severe morbidity or even death. The aim of this study was to evaluate the quality of fetal heart images, obtained during the second-trimester standard anomaly scan (SAS) in cases of CHD, to explore factors associated with a missed prenatal diagnosis.
METHODS: In this case-control study, all cases of a fetus born with isolated severe CHD in the Northwestern region of The Netherlands, between 2015 and 2016, were extracted from the PRECOR registry. Severe CHD was defined as need for surgical repair in the first year postpartum. Each cardiac view (four-chamber view (4CV), three-vessel (3V) view and left and right ventricular outflow tract (LVOT, RVOT) views) obtained during the SAS was scored for technical correctness on a scale of 0 to 5 by two fetal echocardiography experts, blinded to the diagnosis of CHD and whether it was detected prenatally. Quality parameters of the cardiac examination were compared between cases in which CHD was detected and those in which it was missed on the SAS. Regression analysis was used to assess the association of sonographer experience and of screening-center experience with the cardiac examination quality score.
RESULTS: A total of 114 cases of isolated severe CHD at birth were analyzed, of which 58 (50.9%) were missed and 56 (49.1%) were detected on the SAS. The defects comprised transposition of the great arteries (17%), aortic coarctation (16%), tetralogy of Fallot (10%), atrioventricular septal defect (6%), aortic valve stenosis (5%), ventricular septal defect (18%) and other defects (28%). No differences were found in fetal position, obstetric history, maternal age or body mass index (BMI) or gestational age at examination between missed and detected cases. Ninety-two cases had available cardiac images from the SAS. Compared with the detected group, the missed group had significantly lower cardiac examination quality scores (adequate score (≥ 12) in 32% vs 64%; P = 0.002), rate of proper use of magnification (58% vs 84%; P = 0.01) and quality scores for each individual cardiac plane (4CV (2.7 vs 3.9; P < 0.001), 3V view (3.0 vs 3.8; P = 0.02), LVOT view (1.9 vs 3.3; P < 0.001) and RVOT view (1.9 vs 3.3; P < 0.001)). In 49% of missed cases, the lack of detection was due to poor adaptational skills resulting in inadequate images in which the CHD was not clearly visible; in 31%, the images showed an abnormality (mainly septal defects and aortic arch anomalies) which had not been recognized at the time of the scan; and, in 20%, the cardiac planes had been obtained properly but showed normal anatomy. Multivariate regression analysis showed that the volume of SAS performed per year by each sonographer was associated significantly with quality score of the cardiac examination.
CONCLUSIONS: A lack of adaptational skills when performing the SAS, as opposed to circumstantial factors such as BMI or fetal position, appears to play an important role in failure to detect CHD prenatally. The quality of the cardiac views was inadequate significantly more often in undetected compared with detected cases. Despite adequate quality of the images, CHD was not recognized in 31% of cases. A high volume of SAS performed by each sonographer in a large ultrasound center contributes significantly to prenatal detection. In 20% of undetected cases, CHD was not visible even though the quality of the images was good. © 2019 Authors. Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology.
引用
- van Nisselrooij AEL, Teunissen AKK, Clur SA, et al. Why are congenital heart defects being missed? Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2020. PMID: 31131945. doi:10.1002/uog.20358
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。