困难临床与影像学表现下急性缺血性卒中决策过程的变异性:基于横断面访谈式卒中问卷的分析
研究采用访谈式卒中问卷,由50名国际评分者对12例急性缺血性卒中病例判断是否推荐机械取栓,每例含临床摘要与8幅初始多模CT图像。各病例决策多样性从1(100%一致推荐取栓)到0.50(54.2%推荐取栓、45.8%不推荐)不等,仅少数病例达成共识,提示困难病例的治疗决策存在分歧。
要点
- 50名国际评分者对12例病例判断是否行机械取栓,决策多样性范围1至0.50。
- 排除取栓最常见原因为CBV/CBF不匹配小(17%,102/600)、CBV图梗死核心大小(15.2%,91/600)和低NIHSS评分(8.3%,50/600)。
- 所有临床和影像学特征均显著影响取栓决策,但评分者一般特征不是影响因素。
核心结论
- 临床和影像学特征影响卒中取栓决策,但仅在少数病例达成共识,揭示困难病例治疗决策的当前分歧。
研究设计与样本
- 横断面访谈式问卷研究,50名国际评分者评估12例病例,每例含临床信息摘要和8幅初始多模CT代表图像,记录评分者人口学特征和卒中方案,并对不同人口学和病例特征进行单因素和多因素logistic回归分析。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Notwithstanding guidelines, indications for mechanical thrombectomy (MT) in acute ischemic stroke are multifactorial and can be complex. Our aim was to exploratively evaluate decision-making on the advisability of performing MT in cases presented as an interview-administered questionnaire.
METHODS: Fifty international raters assessed 12 cases and decided to recommend or exclude MT. Each case contained a brief summary of clinical information and eight representative images of the initial multimodal CT. The demographic characteristics and stroke protocols were recorded for raters. For each case, the reasons for excluding MT were recorded. Uni- and multivariate logistic regression analysis were performed for the different demographic and case characteristics to identify factors that might influence decision-making.
RESULTS: All raters performed MT (median MTs/hospital/year [IQR], 100 [50-141]) with a median of 7 years of experience as first operator (IQR, 4-12). Per case, diversity in decision-making ranged between 1 (case 6, 100% yes MT) and 0.50 (case 12, 54.2% yes MT and 45.8% no MT). The most common reasons for excluding MT were small CBV/CBF mismatch (17%, 102/600), size of infarct core on the CBV map (15.2%, 91/600), and low NIHSS score (National Institute of Health Stroke Scale, 8.3%, 50/600). All clinical and radiological characteristics significantly affected the decision regarding MT, but the general characteristics of the raters were not a factor.
CONCLUSIONS: Clinical and imaging characteristics influenced the decision regarding MT in stroke. Nevertheless, a consensus was reached in only a minority of cases, revealing the current divergence of opinion regarding therapeutic decisions in difficult cases.
KEY POINTS: • This is the first study to explore differences in decision-making in respect of mechanical thrombectomy in ischemic stroke with complex clinical and radiological constellations. • Fifty experienced international neurointerventionalists answered this interview-administered stroke questionnaire and made decisions as to whether to recommend or disadvise thrombectomy in 12 selected cases. • Diversity in decision-making for thrombectomy ranged from 1 (100% of raters offered the same answer) to 0.5 (50% indicated mechanical thrombectomy). There was a consensus in only a minority of cases, revealing the current disparity of opinion regarding therapeutic decisions in difficult cases.
引用
- Velasco González A, Buerke B, Görlich D, et al. Variability in the decision-making process of acute ischemic stroke in difficult clinical and radiological constellations: analysis based on a cross-sectional interview-administered stroke questionnaire. Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31076863. doi:10.1007/s00330-019-06199-4
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。