儿科放射科医生担任专家证人的短缺:英国儿科放射学会(BSPR)疑似虐待性身体伤害(SPA)影像国家工作组的立场声明
英国儿科放射学会(BSPR)疑似虐待性身体伤害(SPA)影像国家工作组于2019年1月召开会议,探讨医学与法律实践中长期低效问题及跨领域挑战;工作组发布共识意见,强调当前阻碍放射科医生参与法庭专家证人工作的障碍与潜在促进因素,以应对英国专家短缺的紧迫问题。
要点
- 儿童身体虐待的影像诊断是放射学最具挑战性的领域之一。
- 愿意担任专家证人的儿科放射科医生严重短缺,家庭法庭尤为突出。
- 工作组共识指出组织低效、支持不足及参与风险/收益是主要障碍。
核心结论
- 工作组提供共识意见,强调当前阻碍放射科医生向法庭提供意见的障碍及潜在促进因素,以增加愿意参与的放射科医生数量。
研究设计与样本
- 英国儿科放射学会(BSPR)疑似虐待性身体伤害(SPA)影像国家工作组立场声明;工作组由具有向法庭提供SPA专家证人报告经验的放射科医生和神经放射科医生组成,于2019年1月召开会议。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 工作组多名成员已退休或接近退休,英国专家短缺正成为紧迫问题。
- 当前实践存在若干问题,阻碍积极参与。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
One of the most challenging areas of radiological imaging in children is the diagnosis of physical abuse. There is a dearth of paediatric radiologists willing to act as expert witnesses, particularly in the family courts. There are a number of reasons why radiologists may not be interested or willing to put themselves forward to work as expert witnesses in this field. A group of imaging experts recently formed the "British Society of Paediatric Radiology (BSPR) Working Group on Imaging in Suspected Physical Abuse (SPA)". The group comprises radiologists and neuroradiologists with current or previous experience of providing expert witness reports to the court in cases of SPA. The group met in January 2019 to explore pragmatic solutions to the chronic inefficiencies in both medical and legal practices and the challenges that arise from working in a legal arena with different structures, goals, and assessment criteria. Key issues concerned organisational inefficiencies, variable support from National Health Service Trusts and the Royal College of Radiologists to conduct this work, and the risk/benefit of involvement. This work is important for the patient, parents, and society in general, and highly rewarding for clinical practitioners who are involved, but there are several issues with current practices that discourage active participation. With several members of the group either retired or close to retirement, the shortage of experts is becoming a pressing issue within the UK, which requires an engaged multidisciplinary group to come up with creative solutions. Here, the group provide a consensus opinion highlighting the current barriers and potential facilitators to increasing the number of radiologists willing to provide opinions to the court.
引用
- Oates A, Halliday K, Offiah AC, et al. Shortage of paediatric radiologists acting as an expert witness: position statement from the British Society of Paediatric Radiology (BSPR) National Working Group on Imaging in Suspected Physical Abuse (SPA). Clin Radiol. 2019. PMID: 31126587. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2019.04.016
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。