放射学报告中对随访影像检查建议的差异:患者、检查方式和放射科医生的预测因素
这项回顾性研究分析了2016年1月1日至12月31日间一家大型城市四级医院318 366份诊断影像报告(排除乳腺和超声报告),用机器学习算法识别随访建议并用多因素logistic回归分析相关因素。结果显示12.2%的报告包含随访建议,CT检查的建议率最高(OR 4.2),放射科医生性别、是否有培训医生和执业年限不是显著预测因素,但各专科内不同放射科医生间存在2.8至6.7倍的差异。
要点
- 12.2%(38 745/318 366)的放射学报告包含随访影像检查建议。
- CT检查出现随访建议的比值比最高(OR 4.2,95%CI 4.0-4.4,以X线摄影为参照)。
- 调整患者、检查和放射科医生因素后,各专科内不同放射科医生间随访建议概率存在2.8至6.7倍差异。
核心结论
- 调整患者、检查和放射科医生因素后,放射科医生之间在报告中建议随访检查的概率存在相当大的差异。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,分析2016年1月1日至12月31日一家大型城市四级医院诊断影像检查的318 366份报告(排除乳腺和超声报告),随机选取1000份报告人工标注以训练和验证机器学习算法(训练验证集850份,测试集150份),用训练好的算法分类全部318 366份报告,并用多因素logistic回归分析随访建议的可能性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 机器学习算法将38 745/318 366(12.2%)份报告分类为包含随访建议;多因素分析中,年龄每增加1岁随访建议率更高(OR 1.01,95%CI 1.01-1.01),男性患者随访建议率更低(OR 0.9,95%CI 0.9-1.0),CT检查随访建议最常见(与X线摄影相比OR 4.2,95%CI 4.0-4.4);放射科医生性别(P=.54)、是否有培训医生(P=.45)和执业年限(P=.49)总体不是显著预测因素。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Background Variation between radiologists when making recommendations for additional imaging and associated factors are, to the knowledge of the authors, unknown. Clear identification of factors that account for variation in follow-up recommendations might prevent unnecessary tests for incidental or ambiguous image findings. Purpose To determine incidence and identify factors associated with follow-up recommendations in radiology reports from multiple modalities, patient care settings, and imaging divisions. Materials and Methods This retrospective study analyzed 318 366 reports obtained from diagnostic imaging examinations performed at a large urban quaternary care hospital from January 1 to December 31, 2016, excluding breast and US reports. A subset of 1000 reports were randomly selected and manually annotated to train and validate a machine learning algorithm to predict whether a report included a follow-up imaging recommendation (training-and-validation set consisted of 850 reports and test set of 150 reports). The trained algorithm was used to classify 318 366 reports. Multivariable logistic regression was used to determine the likelihood of follow-up recommendation. Additional analysis by imaging subspecialty division was performed, and intradivision and interradiologist variability was quantified. Results The machine learning algorithm classified 38 745 of 318 366 (12.2%) reports as containing follow-up recommendations. Average patient age was 59 years ± 17 (standard deviation); 45.2% (143 767 of 318 366) of reports were from male patients. Among 65 radiologists, 57% (37 of 65) were men. At multivariable analysis, older patients had higher rates of follow-up recommendations (odds ratio [OR], 1.01 [95% confidence interval {CI}: 1.01, 1.01] for each additional year), male patients had lower rates of follow-up recommendations (OR, 0.9; 95% CI: 0.9, 1.0), and follow-up recommendations were most common among CT studies (OR, 4.2 [95% CI: 4.0, 4.4] compared with radiography). Radiologist sex (P = .54), presence of a trainee (P = .45), and years in practice (P = .49) were not significant predictors overall. A division-level analysis showed 2.8-fold to 6.7-fold interradiologist variation. Conclusion Substantial interradiologist variation exists in the probability of recommending a follow-up examination in a radiology report, after adjusting for patient, examination, and radiologist factors. © RSNA, 2019 See also the editorial by Russell in this issue.
引用
- Cochon LR, Kapoor N, Carrodeguas E, et al. Variation in Follow-up Imaging Recommendations in Radiology Reports: Patient, Modality, and Radiologist Predictors. Radiology. 2019. PMID: 31063082. doi:10.1148/radiol.2019182826
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。