磁共振成像对良性前列腺增生分叶分类的精确性与准确性
本研究在140例已知或疑似前列腺癌患者中验证基于MRI的良性前列腺增生分叶分类,两位放射科医生间一致性为64%(κ=0.52),与管理员金标准比较准确度分别为62%(κ=0.49)和67%(κ=0.58),管理员自身重复阅读一致性为87%(κ=0.81)。作者认为该分类是可重复且可靠的工具。
要点
- 两位阅片医生间分叶分类一致性为64%,κ=0.52,属中等一致性。
- 两位阅片医生与管理员金标准比较准确度分别为62%(κ=0.49)和67%(κ=0.58)。
- 管理员重复阅读自身一致性为87%,κ=0.81,属高度一致。
核心结论
- 基于MRI的良性前列腺增生分叶分类是可重复且可靠的工具,可用于研究和临床应用。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性IRB批准研究,纳入140例已知或疑似前列腺癌并转诊至三级学术医疗中心的患者,以管理员指定的分叶分类为金标准,比较两位放射科医生(专科培训后经验分别为5年和11年)的阅片间信度与准确度,并检验管理员的阅片者内信度。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 两位阅片医生间一致性为64%,未加权κ=0.52;所有良性前列腺增生类型(类别)的复合一致性比例为0.67。
- 阅片者1与管理员金标准比较准确度为62%一致性,未加权κ=0.49。
- 阅片者2与管理员金标准比较准确度为67%一致性,未加权κ=0.58。
- 管理员重复阅读的阅片者内信度为87%一致性,未加权κ=0.81,所有类别复合一致性比例为0.87。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To validate the application of a magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-based lobar classification of benign prostatic hyperplasia (BPH) for use in research and clinical management.
METHODS: Two radiologists with 5 and 11 years post-fellowship experience were trained in the lobar classification of BPH using an internally developed atlas of prostate anatomy with example MRI images edited by a third senior radiologist designated as the "administrator" of the study. A study population of 140 patients referred to a tertiary academic medical center with known or suspected prostate cancer was selected by the administrator to test the interrater reliability (IRR; precision) of the classification as well as accuracy of the two readers compared to the administrator as the "gold" standard. The intrarater reliability of repeat readings of the administrator was also examined. Percentage of agreement, proportion of agreement, and Cohen's κ were applied. This was a retrospective IRB-approved study.
RESULTS: IRR (precision) between the two interpreting radiologists was 64% agreement, corresponding to unweighted κ of 0.52. Composite proportion of agreement across all BPH types (categories) for interpreting radiologists was 0.67. Observer accuracy was 62% agreement, unweighted κ 0.49, for observer 1 and 67%, unweighted κ 0.58, for observer 2. Intrarater reliability for the administrator was 87% agreement, unweighted κ 0.81 with composite proportion of agreement across all categories of 0.87.
CONCLUSIONS: MRI lobar classification of BPH is a reproducible and reliable tool for research and clinical applications.
引用
- Wasserman NF, Niendorf E, Spilseth B, et al. Precision and accuracy of magnetic resonance imaging for lobar classification of benign prostatic hyperplasia. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2019. PMID: 30929050. doi:10.1007/s00261-019-01970-z
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。