文献速递骨肌CTMRDR

肩关节不稳患者关节盂骨丢失的影像学定量:系统综述

Imaging Quantification of Glenoid Bone Loss in Patients With Glenohumeral Instability: A Systematic Review.
PubMed 文献 · AJR Am J Roentgenol · 2019-03-05

该系统综述纳入27项研究(1425个肩关节),评估影像学测量前方肩关节不稳关节盂骨丢失的准确性。与关节镜或尸体测量相比,3D MRI准确率100%(4/4)、3D CT 80%(8/10)、2D CT 86%(6/7)、2D MRI 71%(5/7),X线准确率0%(0/4)。最佳拟合圆法常用且准确。

要点

  • CT和MRI(2D或3D)可准确测量前方肩关节不稳的关节盂骨丢失,X线不准确。
  • 3D MRI准确率100%(4/4),3D CT 80%(8/10),2D CT 86%(6/7),2D MRI 71%(5/7),X线0%(0/4)。
  • 最佳拟合圆法(关节盂宽度或Pico表面积)最常用,CT和MRI上均准确。

核心结论

  • CT和MRI(2D或3D)可准确测量前方肩关节不稳的关节盂骨丢失,X线不准确;最佳拟合圆测量技术可靠且准确;现有文献异质性大,未来研究应关注有临床意义的关节盂骨丢失的诊断。

研究设计与样本

  • 系统综述,检索5个数据库至2018年1月,纳入前瞻性或回顾性队列、病例对照或尸体研究设计的原创研究,共27项研究(1425个肩关节),采用QUADAS-2工具进行质量评价。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 与关节镜或尸体测量相比,2D CT准确6/7项研究(86%),3D CT准确8/10项(80%),2D MRI准确5/7项(71%),3D MRI准确4/4项(100%),X线准确0/4项(0%)。
  • 最佳拟合圆法(关节盂宽度或Pico表面积)最常用,CT和MRI上分别准确率86-90%和75-100%。
  • 仅2项研究报告敏感度和特异度,均以关节镜为参考比较CT,骨丢失阈值分别为20%和25%。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 测量前方肩关节不稳的关节盂骨丢失时,可优先选用CT或MRI(2D或3D),X线测量不准确。
  • 最佳拟合圆法(关节盂宽度或Pico表面积)是可靠且准确的测量技术。
  • 仅2项研究报告敏感度和特异度,且阈值不同(20%和25%),解读时需注意。

局限性

  • 现有关于关节盂骨丢失的文献异质性大。
  • 多数偏倚风险来自患者选择和参考标准。
  • 仅2项研究报告敏感度和特异度,且使用不同的骨丢失阈值(20%和25%)。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

To listen to the podcast associated with this article, please select one of the following: iTunes, Google Play, or direct download. OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study is to determine the most accurate imaging techniques to measure glenoid bone loss in anterior glenohumeral instability through a systematic review of existing literature. MATERIALS AND METHODS. We performed a comprehensive literature search of five databases for original research measuring glenoid bone loss at radiography, CT, or MRI, using prospective or retrospective cohort, case-control, or cadaveric study designs up to January 2018. The Quality Assessment of Diagnostic Accuracy Studies-2 tool aided qualitative assessment of the methods. Data extraction included results, index test interobserver agreement, and accuracy analysis. RESULTS. Twenty-seven studies (evaluating 1425 shoulders) met inclusion criteria after full-text review by two independent readers. Glenoid bone loss was assessed, comparing several index tests to nonimaging (n = 18 studies) and imaging (n = 11) reference standards. Compared with arthroscopic or cadaveric measurements, 2D CT was accurate in six of seven studies (86%), 3D CT was accurate in eight of 10 studies (80%), 2D MRI was accurate in five of seven studies (71%), 3D MRI was accurate in four of four studies (100%), and radiographs were accurate in zero of four studies (0%). Best-fit circle methods (glenoid width or Pico surface area) were the most common and both were accurate (86-90% and 75-100%, respectively) using CT and MRI. Studies had good external validity (78%). Most risk for bias arose from patient selection and reference standards. Only two studies reported sensitivity and specificity, both comparing CT to arthroscopy using different bone loss thresholds (20% and 25%). CONCLUSION. CT and MRI (2D or 3D) accurately measure glenoid bone loss in anterior shoulder instability, but radiographs do not. Best-fit circle measurement techniques are reliable and accurate. Current literature about glenoid bone loss is heterogeneous, and future studies should focus on diagnosis of clinically relevant glenoid bone loss.

来源:AJR Am J Roentgenol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Walter WR, Samim M, LaPolla FWZ, et al. Imaging Quantification of Glenoid Bone Loss in Patients With Glenohumeral Instability: A Systematic Review. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2019. PMID: 30835517. doi:10.2214/AJR.18.20504

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。