X线检查剂量调查:我的结果有多准确?
在三个中心收集两个厂商设备上胸片、腹部和腰椎X线检查的剂量面积乘积(DAP)值,计算不同样本量下平均DAP的变异性(以中位值的95%置信区间百分比表示)。小样本(10-20个DAP)时变异性为75-170%;胸部X线需多达800个数据才可达变异性≤10%,腹部和腰椎需多达400个数据才可达最低变异性25%。
要点
- 小样本(10-20个DAP)收集的DAP变异性高达中位值的75-170%。
- 胸部X线需多达800个数据才可达变异性≤10%,腹部和腰椎需多达400个数据才可达最低变异性25%。
- 缩小体重选择范围(67-73 kg或60-80 kg)未能降低腹部和腰椎的最低可达变异性(25%)。
核心结论
- 按监管机构推荐的小样本(10个数据)收集的DAP变异性很高,但通过大幅增加样本量可降至25%(腹部和腰椎)甚至10%(胸部);研究结果可帮助放射科医生和监管机构评估X线剂量调查所得数据的可靠性。
研究设计与样本
- 在三个中心、两个厂商的设备上,收集1至2年内胸片、腹部和腰椎X线检查的DAP值,计算不同样本量下平均DAP的变异性(定义为中位值的95%置信区间百分比),并计算变异性≤25%和≤10%所需的样本量,同时研究按体重缩小患者选择范围(67-73 kg或60-80 kg)的影响。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 小样本(10至20个DAP)时DAP变异性为中位值的75%至170%。
- 胸部X线可达变异性≤10%,需多达800个数据。
- 腹部和腰椎X线最低可达变异性为25%,需多达400个数据,且不受体重选择影响。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 监管机构推荐的10个数据的小样本所收集的DAP变异性很高,需大幅增加样本量以降低变异性。
- 胸部X线需多达800个数据方可达变异性≤10%,腹部和腰椎需多达400个数据方可达最低变异性25%。
- 研究结果可帮助放射科医生和监管机构评估X线剂量调查所得数据的可靠性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To determine the variabilities of dose-area-products (DAP) of frequent X-ray examinations collected for comparison with diagnostic reference levels (DRLs).
METHODS: DAP values of chest, abdomen, and lumbar spine examinations obtained on devices from two manufacturers were collected in three centers over 1 to 2 years. The variability of the average DAP results defined as the 95% confidence interval in percentage of their median value was calculated for increasing sample sizes, each examination and center. We computed the sample sizes yielding variabilities lower or equal to 25% and 10%. The effect of narrowing patient selection based on body weight was also investigated (ranges of 67-73 Kg, or 60-80 Kg).
RESULTS: DAP variabilities ranged from 75 to 170% of the median value when collecting small samples (10 to 20 DAP). To reduce this variability, larger samples are needed, collected over up to 2 years, regardless of the examination and center. A variability ≤ 10% could only be reached for chest X-rays, requiring up to 800 data. For the abdomen and lumbar spine, the lowest achievable variability was 25%, regardless of the body weight selection, requiring up to 400 data.
CONCLUSION: Variabilities in DAP collected through small samples of ten data as recommended by authorities are very high, but can be reduced down to 25% (abdomen and lumbar spine) or even 10% (chest) through a substantial increase in sample sizes. Our findings could assist radiologists and regulatory authorities in estimating the reliability of the data obtained when performing X-ray dose surveys.
KEY POINTS: • Low but reasonable variabilities cannot be reached with samples sized as recommended by regulatory authorities. Higher numbers of DAP values are required to reduce the variability. • Variabilities of 10% for the chest and 25% for abdomen and lumbar spine examinations are achievable, provided large samples of data are collected over 1 year. • Our results could help radiologists and authorities interpret X-rays dose surveys.
引用
- Taylor S, Van Muylem A, Howarth N, et al. X-ray examination dose surveys: how accurate are my results? Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30877467. doi:10.1007/s00330-019-06055-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。