45-49岁女性每年一次乳腺X线筛查与50-69岁女性每两年一次筛查:在有组织筛查环境下的性能指标比较
在意大利一项筛查规划中分析1,465,335次乳腺X线检查,比较45-49岁年度筛查与50-54岁、55-69岁每两年筛查的性能指标。年轻女性在第二次及后续筛查中的累积召回率为年长组的2至3倍,手术活检率差异有限。作者认为结果虽令人鼓舞,但需进一步研究,尤其需关注间期癌发生率。
要点
- 45-49岁女性在第二次及后续筛查中的累积召回率约为50-54岁和55-69岁女性的2至3倍,首次筛查召回率仅轻度升高。
- 年轻女性与年长女性在累积手术活检率上的差异中等,手术活检阳性预测值差异尤其小。
- 作者认为结果令人鼓舞,但需进一步研究,尤其需关注间期癌发生率。
核心结论
- 45-49岁女性在第二次及后续筛查中的累积召回率是50-54岁和55-69岁女性的2至3倍,而累积手术活检率差异中等。
研究设计与样本
- 在意大利一项有组织筛查规划中分析1,465,335次乳腺X线检查,比较45-49岁每年一次筛查与50-54岁、55-69岁每两年一次筛查的性能指标。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 召回率:首次筛查,45-49岁103.6/1000 vs 50-54岁93.5/1000(率比1.11),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁93.2/1000(率比1.11);第二次及后续筛查,45-49岁208.9/1000 vs 50-54岁99.7/1000(率比2.10),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁75.5/1000(率比2.77)。
- 有创评估率:首次筛查,45-49岁23.0/1000 vs 50-54岁24.5/1000(率比0.94),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁24.6/1000(率比0.94);第二次及后续筛查,45-49岁35.8/1000 vs 50-54岁22.0/1000(率比1.63),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁23.0/1000(率比1.56)。
- 手术活检率:首次筛查,45-49岁5.9/1000 vs 50-54岁8.6/1000(率比0.68),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁13.2/1000(率比0.45);第二次及后续筛查,45-49岁11.5/1000 vs 50-54岁8.5/1000(率比1.35),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁13.0/1000(率比0.88)。
- 总检出率:首次筛查,45-49岁4.3/1000 vs 50-54岁6.7/1000(率比0.63),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁11.7/1000(率比0.37);第二次及后续筛查,45-49岁8.9/1000 vs 50-54岁6.8/1000(率比1.30),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁12.0/1000(率比0.74)。
- 手术活检总阳性预测值:首次筛查,45-49岁72.8% vs 50-54岁78.0%(率比0.93),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁88.9%(率比0.82);第二次及后续筛查,45-49岁77.2% vs 50-54岁80.5%(率比0.96),45-49岁 vs 55-69岁92.7%(率比0.83)。
局限性
- 原文结论指出结果虽令人鼓舞,但需进一步研究,尤其需关注间期癌发生率。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To compare the results of 5 years of annual mammography screening at age 45-49 with the results of 5 years of biennial screening at age 50-54 and 55-69.
METHODS: In an Italian screening programme, data from 1,465,335 mammograms were analysed. Recall rates, invasive assessment rates, surgical biopsy (including excisional biopsy and definitive surgical treatment) rates, and cancer detection rates were calculated for the first screen (first) and, cumulatively, for the second and subsequent screens (second+).
RESULTS: The rate ratios between younger women and the two groups of older ones were (in parentheses, original figures per 1000 mammograms if not otherwise specified): recall rate: first 1.11 (103.6 vs. 93.5) and 1.11 (vs. 93.2), second+ 2.10 (208.9 vs. 99.7) and 2.77 (vs. 75.5); invasive assessment rate: first 0.94 (23.0 vs. 24.5) and 0.94 (vs. 24.6), second+ 1.63 (35.8 vs. 22.0) and 1.56 (vs. 23.0); surgical biopsy rate: first 0.68 (5.9 vs. 8.6) and 0.45 (vs. 13.2), second+ 1.35 (11.5 vs. 8.5) and 0.88 (vs. 13.0); total detection rate: first 0.63 (4.3 vs. 6.7) and 0.37 (vs. 11.7), second+ 1.30 (8.9 vs. 6.8) and 0.74 (vs. 12.0); total positive predictive value of surgical biopsy: first 0.93 (72.8% vs. 78.0%) and 0.82 (vs. 88.9%), second+ 0.96 (77.2% vs. 80.5%) and 0.83 (vs. 92.7%).
CONCLUSION: Younger women experienced two to threefold higher cumulative recall rates at second+ screens and limited differences in surgical biopsy rate. Albeit encouraging, these results must be completed with further investigation, especially on interval cancer incidence.
KEY POINTS: • At repeated screens, cumulative recall rate was two- to threefold higher for younger women. • Differences in cumulative surgical referral and surgical biopsy rates were moderate. • Differences in positive predictive value of surgical biopsy were particularly small.
引用
- Bucchi L, Ravaioli A, Baldacchini F, et al. Annual mammography at age 45-49 years and biennial mammography at age 50-69 years: comparing performance measures in an organised screening setting. Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30887204. doi:10.1007/s00330-019-06050-w
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。