使用商业MR序列在不同平台测量质子密度脂肪分数的 agreement 与可重复性:多厂商、多机构体模实验
该体模实验用11个不同脂肪比例(0-50重量%)的脂肪-水乳胶体模,在西门子1.5T和3.0T、飞利浦3.0T、GE 1.5T和3.0T设备上,用商业化学位移MR序列及西门子1.5T和3.0T的MR波谱序列(HISTO)估算PDFF,评估商业序列间一致性、可重复性及重测重复性。结果显示PDFF测量重复性高(重复性系数0.31%-1.58%),但跨序列、厂商和场强不可重复(可重复性系数总体9.0%,化学位移序列间10.6%),21对商业序列比较中19对存在显著偏差。作者建议纵向随访肝脂肪变性时使用同一序列和设备。
要点
- PDFF测量重复性高,重复性系数0.31%-1.58%(绝对值)。
- 跨商业序列、厂商和场强不可重复,总体可重复性系数9.0%。
- 21对商业序列比较中19对存在显著偏差,平均偏差范围-4.48%至8.15%。
核心结论
- PDFF测量用商业MR序列重复性高,但跨不同序列、设备厂商和场强不可重复;建议纵向随访肝脂肪变性时使用同一序列和设备。
研究设计与样本
- 多厂商、多机构体模实验;构建11个不同脂肪比例(0-50重量%)的脂肪-水乳胶体模;使用西门子1.5T和3.0T、飞利浦3.0T、GE 1.5T和3.0T设备上的商业化学位移MR序列及西门子1.5T和3.0T的MR波谱序列(HISTO)估算PDFF;用Bland-Altman分析评估商业序列间一致性,用可重复性系数评估跨序列可重复性,用重复性系数评估重测重复性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 商业序列PDFF测量的重复性系数为0.31%至1.58%(绝对值);21对商业序列比较中19对存在统计学显著偏差,平均偏差范围-4.48%至8.15%(绝对值);所有商业序列间PDFF测量的可重复性系数为9.0%(绝对值),所有化学位移MR序列间为10.6%(绝对值)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者建议纵向随访肝脂肪变性使用商业MR序列测量PDFF时,采用同一序列和设备。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The aim of this study was to evaluate the agreement and reproducibility of proton density fat fraction (PDFF) measurements using commercial magnetic resonance (MR) sequences across different imagers, vendors, and field strengths via a phantom experiment.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Eleven fat-water emulsion phantoms of varying fat proportions (ie, 0-50 weight%) were constructed. Phantom PDFFs were estimated using commercial chemical shift-based MR imaging sequences with Siemens 1.5 T and 3.0 T, Philips 3.0 T, and GE 1.5 T and 3.0 T imagers, and MR spectroscopic sequences (HISTO) with Siemens 1.5 T and 3.0 T imagers. Agreement among the estimated PDFF values between commercial sequences was evaluated using Bland-Altman analysis. Reproducibility of the PDFF measurements across commercial sequences was evaluated using the reproducibility coefficient. The test-retest repeatability of the PDFF measurements was evaluated using the repeatability coefficient.
RESULTS: The repeatability coefficient of the PDFF measurements was 0.31% to 1.58% for the absolute PDFF value for commercial sequences. Statistically significant biases in the estimated PDFF were noted in 19 of 21 pairwise comparisons of commercial sequences (range of mean biases, -4.48% to 8.15% for the absolute PDFF value). The reproducibility coefficient of PDFF measurements was 9.0% for the absolute PDFF value over all commercial sequences and 10.6% for the absolute PDFF value over all chemical shift-based MR imaging sequences.
CONCLUSIONS: The measurement of the PDFF is highly repeatable with commercial MR sequences but is not reproducible across different sequences, imager vendors, and field strengths. The use of the same sequence and imager is therefore recommended for the longitudinal follow-up of hepatic steatosis using commercial MR sequences for PDFF measurements.
引用
- Jang JK, Lee SS, Kim B, et al. Agreement and Reproducibility of Proton Density Fat Fraction Measurements Using Commercial MR Sequences Across Different Platforms: A Multivendor, Multi-Institutional Phantom Experiment. Invest Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30913055. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000561
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。