阅片者与患者参数对荧光透视膀胱输尿管反流分级中末帧保留图像性能的影响
该回顾性研究分析了191例排尿性膀胱尿道造影中末帧保留图像与点片曝光图像对膀胱输尿管反流分级的一致性,发现经验丰富阅片者总体一致性几乎完美且误分类率低于2%,经验较少者一致性中等且误分类率低于4%;经验丰富者最常见误分类为点片3级而末帧保留2级,经验较少者最常见为漏判反流;作者认为末帧保留图像上的2级反流可能需要补充点片曝光图像评估。
要点
- 经验丰富阅片者对末帧保留图像与点片曝光图像的反流分级总体一致性几乎完美,误分类率低于2%。
- 经验较少阅片者总体一致性中等,误分类率低于4%,最常见误分类为完全漏判反流。
- 阅片者对分级的确定程度越高,一致性和误分类率表现越好。
核心结论
- 末帧保留图像上的2级反流可能需要补充点片曝光图像评估;否则,阅片者对末帧保留图像分级的确定程度可能有助于判断补充点片曝光图像是否有益。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性评估191例连续排尿性膀胱尿道造影检查的肾脏窝末帧保留图像与点片曝光图像,由盲法阅片者判读,采用Kappa检验评估反流分级一致性及阅片者和患者参数的影响,采用Pearson积矩相关评估患者参数对阅片者分级确定程度的影响。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 经验丰富阅片者总体一致性几乎完美,总体误分类点估计低于2%。
- 经验较少阅片者总体一致性中等,总体误分类点估计低于4%。
- 经验丰富阅片者最常见误分类为点片曝光图像判为3级而对应末帧保留图像判为2级。
- 经验较少阅片者最常见误分类为完全漏判反流。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片者对末帧保留图像分级的确定程度可能有助于判断是否需要补充点片曝光图像。
- 作者认为末帧保留图像上的2级反流可能需要补充点片曝光图像评估。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this study is to determine the effect of different reader and patient parameters on the degree of agreement and the rate of misclassification of vesicoureteric reflux grading on last-image-hold frames in relation to spot-exposed frames from voiding cystourethrography (VCUG) as well as to determine the nature of reflux misclassification on last-image-hold frames. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Blinded readers conducted a retrospective evaluation of last-image-hold and spot-exposed frames of the renal fossae from 191 sequential VCUG examinations performed during a five-year period. Kappa tests were used to determine the agreement between reflux gradings and to assess the impact of reader and patient parameters. Pearson product-moment correlations were used to evaluate the effect of patient parameters on reader level of certainty regarding reflux grading. RESULTS. We measured almost perfect overall agreement for more experienced readers and substantial overall agreement for less experienced readers. Point estimates of overall misclassification were less than 2% for more experienced readers and less than 4% for less experienced readers. The readers' level of certainty about reflux grading had a positive impact on agreement values and misclassification rates. Experienced readers' most common misclassification was assigning reflux a grade of 3 on a spot-exposed frame and a grade of 2 on an equivalent last-image-hold frame. Inexperienced readers' most common misclassification involved missing reflux altogether. CONCLUSION. Instances of grade 2 reflux on last-image-hold frames may warrant supplemental evaluation with spot-exposed frames. Otherwise, a reader's level of certainty regarding reflux grading on a last-image-hold frame may help determine whether a supplemental spot-exposed frame would be beneficial.
引用
- Mian AY, Mills IP, Sheridan AD, et al. Effect of Reader and Patient Parameters on the Performance of Last-Image-Hold for Fluoroscopic Grading of Vesicoureteric Reflux. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2019. PMID: 30807219. doi:10.2214/AJR.18.20273
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。