定性超声培训:界定学习曲线
本研究比较两名受训者学习腹股沟与肩部超声时与专家的诊断一致性,以κ分析定义培训终点为与专家一致率至少80%,并用累积和回顾性分析逐例评估表现。结果显示腹股沟疝平均需约70例、肩部平均需约80例达到胜任,不同结构学习曲线存在差异,累积和能敏感提示个别学习困难。
要点
- 培训终点定义为与专家诊断一致率至少80%,腹股沟平均约70例、肩部平均约80例。
- 腹股沟区腹股沟疝所需例数高于股疝;肩部冈上肌腱与冈下肌腱最具挑战性。
- 累积和回顾性分析可逐例敏感反映受训者表现,及时发现个别学习困难。
核心结论
- κ分析显示各检查区域内不同结构的学习曲线存在差异,序贯κ值符合S形学习曲线。
- 达到满意一致率所需例数被建议作为超声培训课程的最低要求。
- 累积和是受训者表现的敏感指标,前瞻性使用可及时启动额外培训支持。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性记录两名受训者腹股沟与肩部超声表现,并与专家意见比较诊断。
- 使用专用表格记录,采用κ分析评估一致性,培训终点定义为与专家一致率至少80%。
- 回顾性对数据应用累积和分析,逐例评估表现。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 培训终点定义为受训者与专家诊断一致率至少80%。
- 腹股沟疝报告平均约70例可达胜任,腹股沟疝所需例数高于股疝。
- 肩部平均约80例可达胜任,冈上肌腱与冈下肌腱为最具挑战性的结构。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者建议将达到满意一致率所需例数作为超声培训课程的最低要求。
- 作者认为累积和可前瞻性用于及时发现个别学习困难并快速启动额外培训支持。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To assess the developing competence of two trainees learning groin and shoulder ultrasound when compared to an expert practitioner.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Specific pro formas were used to record ultrasound trainee performance in each scan region and their diagnosis was compared to the opinion of the expert. The data derived were reviewed using kappa analysis and training end points were defined as a minimum 80% trainee agreement with the expert. Retrospectively, cumulative sum analysis was applied to the data to assess case-by-case performance.
RESULTS: For groin hernias, reporting an average of 70 examinations was required to become competent and inguinal hernias required higher numbers of examinations than femoral hernias. For shoulders, an average of 80 examinations was required and the supraspinatus and infraspinatus tendons proved the most challenging structures.
CONCLUSIONS: Kappa analysis demonstrated a differential in the learning curves for individual structures within each examination region. Sequential kappa scores are consistent with a sigmoid learning curve. The numbers required to achieve satisfactory agreement are suggested as required minima for ultrasound training curricula. Cumulative sum analysis provided a sensitive indicator of trainee performance, quickly highlighting individual learning difficulties when they arose. Its prospective use can ensure extra training support is instigated quickly and appropriately.
引用
- Mullaney PJ. Qualitative ultrasound training: defining the learning curve. Clin Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30732923. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2018.12.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。