比较筛查中数字化乳腺断层摄影的两种显示方案:厚层与厚层加薄层的特异度和敏感度
该回顾性研究从RETomo试验实验组随机选取894例DBT(含12例癌)评估特异度,另用24例癌(其中8例与第一组重叠)混于276例阴性DBT中评估敏感度,共28例癌64次判读。结果显示简化方案(仅1 cm厚层)较标准方案(厚层加1 mm薄层)阅读时间缩短20%–30%、假阳性减少,但敏感度可能下降。
要点
- 简化方案(仅厚层)敏感度82.8%,标准方案(厚层加薄层)敏感度90.6%。
- 随机筛查设置下简化方案特异度97.9%,标准方案特异度96.3%。
- 简化方案阅读时间较标准方案缩短20%–30%,但可能对敏感度有负面影响。
核心结论
- 简化方案(仅厚层加合成2D)缩短阅读时间并减少假阳性,但可能对敏感度有负面影响。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,从RETomo试验实验组随机选取894例DBT(含12例癌)由两名放射科医生判读评估特异度;另取24例癌(8例与第一组重叠)混于276例阴性DBT中,共28例癌64次判读评估敏感度;两种方案判读间隔3个月洗脱期;仅评估筛查判读为阳性的女性;方差估计考虑重复测量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 简化方案敏感度82.8%(53/64,95%CI 67.2–92.2),标准方案敏感度90.6%(95%CI 80.2–95.8)。
- 随机筛查设置下简化方案特异度97.9%(1727/1764,95%CI 97.1–98.5),标准方案特异度96.3%(95%CI 95.3–97.1)。
- 简化方案读者间一致性为0.68,标准方案为0.54。
- 简化方案中位阅读时间较标准方案缩短20%–30%。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Tomosynthesis (DBT) has proven to be more sensitive than digital mammography, but it requires longer reading time. We retrospectively compared accuracy and reading times of a simplified protocol with 1-cm-thick slabs versus a standard protocol of slabs + 1-mm-spaced planes, both integrated with synthetic 2D.
METHODS: We randomly selected 894 DBTs (including 12 cancers) from the experimental arm of the RETomo trial. DBTs were read by two radiologists to estimate specificity. A second set of 24 cancers (8 also present in the first set) mixed within 276 negative DBTs was read by two radiologists. In total, 28 cancers with 64 readings were used to estimate sensitivity. Radiologists read with both protocols separated by a 3-month washout. Only women that were positive at the screening reading were assessed. Variance was estimated taking into account repeated measures.
RESULTS: Sensitivity was 82.8% (53/64, 95% confidence interval (95% CI) 67.2-92.2) and 90.6% (95% CI 80.2-95.8) with simplified and standard protocols, respectively. In the random screening setting, specificity was 97.9% (1727/1764, 95% CI 97.1-98.5) and 96.3% (95% CI 95.3-97.1), respectively. Inter-reader agreement was 0.68 and 0.54 with simplified and standard protocols, respectively. Median reading times with simplified protocol were 20% to 30% shorter than with standard protocol.
CONCLUSIONS: A simplified protocol reduced reading time and false positives but may have a negative impact on sensitivity.
KEY POINTS: • The adoption of digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) in screening, more sensitive than mammography, could be limited by its potential effect on the radiologists' workload, i.e., increased reading time and fatigue. • A DBT simplified protocol with slab only, compared to a standard protocol (slab plus planes) both integrated with synthetic 2D, reduced time and false positives but had a negative impact on sensitivity.
引用
- Iotti V, Giorgi Rossi P, Nitrosi A, et al. Comparing two visualization protocols for tomosynthesis in screening: specificity and sensitivity of slabs versus planes plus slabs. Eur Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30737568. doi:10.1007/s00330-018-5978-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。