数字乳腺断层摄影能否在筛查人群中准确预测边界清晰的肿块是良性还是恶性
本研究在筛查人群中评估数字乳腺断层摄影(DBT)通过边缘锐利度预测边界清晰肿块良恶性的能力。共纳入121个在DBT上分类为边界清晰的肿块(25个恶性,96个良性),按边缘锐利部分占全部边缘的百分比分为4类。DBT上类别3或4的51个病灶中48个(94.1%)为良性;正向类别变化的67个病灶中65个(97.01%)为良性;DBT类别1的病灶恶性概率为45.4%(20/44),高于2DDM的22.72%(20/88)(卡方检验P<0.001)。
要点
- DBT上边缘锐利部分>50%(类别3或4)的51个病灶中48个(94.1%)为良性。
- DBT正向类别变化的67个病灶中65个(97.01%)为良性。
- DBT类别1的病灶恶性概率为45.4%(20/44),高于2DDM的22.72%(20/88)(P<0.001)。
核心结论
- 使用正向类别变化预测边界清晰病灶为良性时准确率为97%,DBT上>50%边缘锐利时准确率为94%。
研究设计与样本
- 在筛查人群中评估边界清晰肿块,于配准的二维数字乳腺摄影(2DDM)和DBT上按边缘锐利部分占全部边缘的百分比分类(类别1=0-25%,类别2=26-50%,类别3=51-75%,类别4=76-100%),分析2DDM与DBT间类别变化;759个病灶中121个在DBT上分类为边界清晰的肿块被纳入(25个恶性,96个良性)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 类别1=可见锐利边界占全部边缘0-25%;类别2=26-50%;类别3=51-75%;类别4=76-100%;DBT类别低于2DDM为负向变化,高于为正向变化;DBT类别3或4的51个病灶中48个(94.1%)为良性;正向类别变化组67个病灶中65个(97.01%)为良性;无变化或负向变化组54个病灶中23个(42.6%)为恶性;DBT类别1恶性概率45.4%(20/44)vs 2DDM 22.72%(20/88)(卡方检验P<0.001);良性病灶中2DDM类别3或4为8/96 vs DBT类别3或4为48/96(Fisher精确检验P<0.000527)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To evaluate whether digital breast tomosynthesis (DBT) can predict if circumscribed masses are benign or malignant by assessing margin sharpness.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Circumscribed masses were evaluated on co-registered two-dimensional digital mammography (2DDM) and DBT. Lesions were categorised as follows: category 1=visible sharp border 0-25% of the total margin; category 2 = 26-50% category 3= 51-75%, and category 4=76-100%. Changes in category between 2DDM and DBT were analysed; if the category was lower on DBT the change was negative, if higher the change was positive.
RESULTS: Of 759 lesions, 121 masses classified as circumscribed on DBT were included; 25 were malignant and 96 benign. Of the benign lesions, 8/96 were within category 3 or 4 on 2DDM compared with 48/96 benign lesions within category 3 or 4 on DBT (Fisher's exact test p<0.000527). Forty-eight of 51 (94.1%) lesions categorised as 3 or 4 on DBT were benign and 65/67 (97.01%) of the positive category change group were benign. Lesions in category 1 on DBT had 45.4% chance of being malignant (20/44) compared with 22.72% (20/88) on 2DDM (chi-squared test p<0.001). Sixty-five of 67 (97.01%) lesions in the positive category change group were benign and 23/54 (42.6%) lesions with either no or negative category change were malignant.
CONCLUSION: The present study demonstrates 97% accuracy in predicting circumscribed lesions as benign when using positive category change and 94% accuracy when >50% of the margin is sharply defined on DBT.
引用
- Wasan RK, Morel JC, Iqbal A, et al. Can digital breast tomosynthesis accurately predict whether circumscribed masses are benign or malignant in a screening population? Clin Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30745157. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2018.12.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。