即使使用三维计算机断层扫描,采用比值-「最佳拟合圆」法时关于圆尺寸和骨缺损宽度的共识仍不足
本研究对26例患者共52个肩关节CT(26个二维CT、26个三维CT)由6名评估者在两个时间点采用比值法(「最佳拟合圆」)测量肩胛盂骨缺损,发现圆直径、骨缺损宽度和骨缺损百分比的测量差异均存在且三维CT测量值显著小于二维CT,三维CT的评估者间一致性优于二维CT,作者认为该方法不能稳定量化肩胛盂骨缺损,圆直径的选取是误差来源。
要点
- 采用「最佳拟合圆」比值法测量肩胛盂骨缺损时,圆直径的选取存在评估者间差异,是测量误差的来源。
- 三维CT测得的圆直径、骨缺损宽度和骨缺损百分比均显著小于二维CT,且三维CT的评估者间一致性优于二维CT。
- 作者认为不应仅凭骨缺损程度决定是否行骨性手术,而应界定「临界」缺损大小并结合其他患者特异性因素。
核心结论
- 比值法在所有肩胛盂参数上均存在变异,即使在三维CT上也不能稳定量化肩胛盂骨缺损,在决定合适的手术治疗时必须考虑到这一点。
- 不应仅凭肩胛盂骨缺损程度决定支持或反对骨性手术,更重要的是界定「临界」缺损大小并同时考虑其他患者特异性因素,以便选择最佳治疗方案。
- 应用「最佳拟合圆」是使用比值法时的误差来源,因此测量圆直径时应谨慎。
研究设计与样本
- 本研究为评估者间与评估者内可靠性研究,证据等级为III级。
- 纳入26例肩关节前盂骨缺损患者的52个肩关节CT(26个二维CT、26个三维CT),由6名评估者在时间点0(T0)和至少3周后(T1)采用比值法(「最佳拟合圆」)评估肩胛盂骨缺损。
- 比较二维CT与三维CT在圆尺寸(圆直径)、骨缺损测量宽度和计算所得骨缺损百分比(长度-宽度比值)上的评估者间与评估者内差异,采用组内相关系数(ICC)确定评估者间和评估者内一致性。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 二维CT圆直径平均差异为2.0 ± 1.9 mm,三维CT为1.8 ± 1.5 mm(p < 0.01)。
- 二维CT骨缺损平均宽度为1.9 ± 1.7 mm,三维CT为1.7 ± 1.5 mm(p < 0.01)。
- 骨缺损百分比平均差异二维CT为5.1 ± 4.8%,三维CT为4.8 ± 4.5%(p < 0.01)。
- 圆直径ICC范围为0.76-0.83,骨缺损宽度ICC范围为0.76-0.86,骨缺损百分比ICC范围为0.85-0.91,总体三维CT一致性优于二维CT。
- T0与T1比较,圆直径、骨缺损宽度和骨缺损百分比均无显著差异;三维CT的圆直径、骨缺损宽度和骨缺损百分比测量值在T0和T1均显著小于二维CT(p < 0.01)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 采用「最佳拟合圆」比值法测量肩胛盂骨缺损时,圆直径的选取是误差来源,测量圆直径时应谨慎。
- 不应仅凭肩胛盂骨缺损程度决定支持或反对骨性手术,而应界定「临界」缺损大小并同时考虑其他患者特异性因素。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Glenoid bone integrity is crucial for shoulder stability. The purpose of this study was to investigate a non-invasive method for quantifying bone loss regarding reliability and accuracy to detect glenoid bone deficiency in standard two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D) computed tomography (CT) measurements at different time points. It was hypothesized that the diameter of the circle used would significantly differ between raters, rendering this method inaccurate and not allowing for an exact estimation of glenoid defect size.
METHODS: Fifty-two shoulder CTs from 26 patients (26 2D-CTs; 26 3D-CTs) with anterior glenoid bone defects were evaluated by 6 raters at time 0 (T0) and at least 3 weeks after (T1) to assess the glenoid bone defect using the ratio method ("best fit circle"). Inter- and intra-rater differences concerning circle dimensions (circle diameter), measured width of bone loss and calculated percentage of bone loss (length-width-ratio) were compared in 2D- versus 3D-CT scans. The intraclass coefficient (ICC) was used to determine the inter- and intra-rater agreement.
RESULTS: The mean circle diameter difference in 2D-CT was 2.0 ± 1.9 mm versus 1.8 ± 1.5 mm in 3D-CT, respectively (p < 0.01). Mean width of bone loss in 2D-CT was 1.9 ± 1.7 mm compared to 1.7 ± 1.5 mm in 3D-CT, respectively (p < 0.01). The mean difference of bone loss percentage was 5.1 ± 4.8% in 2D-CT and 4.8 ± 4.5% in 3D-CT (p < 0.01). No significant differences concerning circle diameter, bone loss width and bone loss percentage were detected comparing T0 and T1. Circle diameter, bone loss width and bone loss percentage measurements in 3D-CT were significantly smaller compared to 2D-CT at T0 and T1 (p < 0.01). Agreement (ICC) was fair to good for all indicators of circle diameter (range 0.76-0.83), bone loss width (range 0.76-0.86) and percentage of bone loss (range 0.85-0.91). Overall, 3D-CT showed superior agreement compared to 2D-CT.
CONCLUSION: The ratio method varies in all glenoid parameters and is not valid for consistently quantifying glenoid bone defects even in 3D computed tomography. This must be taken into consideration when determining proper surgical treatment. The degree of glenoid bone loss alone should not be used to decide for or against a bony procedure. Rather, it is more important to define a defect size as "critical" and to also take other patient-specific factors into consideration so that the best treatment option can be undertaken. Application of the "best fitting circle" is a source of error when using the ratio method; therefore, care should be taken when measuring the circle diameter.
LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: III.
引用
- Lacheta L, Herbst E, Voss A, et al. Insufficient consensus regarding circle size and bone loss width using the ratio-"best fit circle"-method even with three-dimensional computed tomography. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc. 2019. PMID: 30725122. doi:10.1007/s00167-019-05391-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。