膝关节MRI基层医疗申请实践:非创伤性膝痛对ACR适宜性标准的依从性及其对临床管理的影响
回顾性分析某大型公立城市医院基层诊所18个月内连续196例非创伤性膝痛膝关节MRI,按ACR适宜性标准 retrospectively 评分,57%为「通常适宜」、43%为「通常不适宜」。MRI改变临床管理的比例在「通常适宜」组26%、「通常不适宜」组20%(P<.05),两组中分别有70%和61%存在中重度骨关节炎;结论认为对AC的依从性低。
要点
- 57%的膝关节MRI为「通常适宜」,43%为「通常不适宜」,依从性低。
- 「通常适宜」组26%的MRI改变了临床管理,「通常不适宜」组为20%(P<.05)。
- 「通常适宜」组70%、「通常不适宜」组61%存在中重度骨关节炎。
核心结论
- 基层诊所申请的非创伤性膝痛膝关节MRI对ACR适宜性标准的依从性低。
- 作者认为还需关注减少那些不影响临床管理的「适宜」检查,例如影像上已有中重度骨关节炎的病例。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,纳入某大型公立城市医院基层诊所18个月内连续196例因非创伤性膝痛申请的膝关节MRI。
- 通过病历回顾计算非创伤性膝痛ACR适宜性标准(AC)评分,并评估膝关节MRI是否改变临床管理,同时进行膝关节骨关节炎分级。
- 对适宜与不适宜MRI之间的年龄、体质指数、性别和种族差异进行检验。
诊断标准与关键数值
- AC评分7-9分定义为「通常适宜」,1-3分定义为「通常不适宜」。
- 57%(108膝)为「通常适宜」,43%(8膝)为「通常不适宜」(P>.1);原文括注的膝数与百分比不一致,按上下文43%应为多数膝,原文此处表述有矛盾。
临床应用与阅片要点
- ACR适宜性标准可用于评估基层非创伤性膝痛膝关节MRI申请的适宜性。
- 作者认为需关注减少不影响临床管理的「适宜」检查,如影像上已有中重度骨关节炎的病例。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To evaluate the appropriateness of MRI ordering practices and their effect on clinical management for nontraumatic knee pain at the primary care clinics of a large public urban hospital.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In all, 196 consecutive MRIs for nontraumatic knee pain ordered from primary care clinics in a large public urban hospital over an 18-month period were studied. ACR Appropriateness Criteria (AC) scores for nontraumatic knee pain were retrospectively calculated from medical record reviews. The record was also reviewed to assess whether knee MRI changed clinical management. Knee osteoarthritis grading was performed. Tests were performed for differences in age, body mass index (BMI), gender, and ethnicity among appropriate and inappropriate MRIs.
RESULTS: Of the MRIs, 57% (108 knees) had "usually appropriate" (ie, 7-9) and 43% (8 knees) had "usually not appropriate" (ie, 1-3) AC scores (P > .1). Clinical management was changed in 26% of knees with "usually appropriate" and 20% of knees with "usually inappropriate" scores (P < .05), and 70% of the knees with "usually appropriate" and 61% of the knee with "usually not appropriate" scores had moderate to severe osteoarthritis. Age, BMI, gender, and ethnicity had no significant effect on AC scores.
CONCLUSION: In patients referred from primary care for MRI for nontraumatic knee pain, adherence to AC was low. Additional focus on reducing "appropriate" studies that do not impact clinical management (eg, cases with radiographically evident moderate to severe osteoarthritis) is also warranted.
引用
- Gonzalez FM, Kerchberger JM, Robertson DD, et al. Knee MRI Primary Care Ordering Practices for Nontraumatic Knee Pain: Compliance With ACR Appropriateness Criteria and Its Effect on Clinical Management. J Am Coll Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30552001. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2018.10.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。