文献速递泌尿生殖腹部CTMR

使用不同体积测量方法估算分肾功能:MRI与CT的个体间及个体内比较

Estimation of split renal function using different volumetric methods: inter- and intraindividual comparison between MRI and CT.
PubMed 文献 · Abdom Radiol (NY) · 2019-01-01

回顾性纳入29例在3个月内接受腹部增强MRI和增强CT的患者,由两名独立读者用肾皮质体积测量(RCV)和改良椭球体积(MELV)估算分肾功能(SRF)。两种方法所得SRF平均差异<1%;RCV在CT与MRI间一致性很好,读者间一致性RCVCT强(r=0.89)、RCVMRI好(r=0.69),MELVCT/MRI仅中等(r=0.54;r=0.50);作者推荐用RCV估算SRF,主要使用CT数据集,MRI数据集RCV可获相当准确性和可靠性并避免不必要辐射暴露。

要点

  • RCV法估算SRF在CT与MRI间一致性很好,读者间相关性RCVCT r=0.89、RCVMRI r=0.69。
  • MELV法读者间一致性仅中等(MELVCT r=0.54;MELVMRI r=0.50)且数值范围大。
  • 读者自身一致性除MELVMRI(r=0.54,平均偏倚和数值范围大)外均优秀。

核心结论

  • 使用RCV法时,增强MRI估算SRF的准确性和可靠性与增强CT几乎相当;MELV法估算SRF在准确性和可靠性上劣于RCV法。

研究设计与样本

  • 回顾性研究纳入29例患者(18男11女,平均年龄62.8±12.4岁),均在3个月内接受腹部增强MRI和增强CT;两名独立读者(R1/R2)用相应半自动软件工具在所有数据集上完成RCV和MELV测量;RCV使用动脉期数据集,MELV使用静脉期数据集;统计采用单因素方差分析、双尾Student t检验、Pearson相关和Bland-Altman图,P≤0.05为有统计学意义。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 所有数据集中两种体积测量法所得SRF几乎相同,平均差异<1%;Bland-Altman分析显示R1/R2在CT与MRI的RCV间一致性很好;读者间一致性RCVCT强(r=0.89)、RCVMRI好(r=0.69);MELVCT/MRI读者间一致性仅中等(r=0.54;r=0.50)且数值范围大;读者自身一致性除MELVMRI外均优秀(RCVCT r=0.93、RCVMRI r=0.98、MELVCT r=0.89、MELVMRI r=0.54,MELVMRI平均偏倚和数值范围大)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者推荐使用RCV法估算SRF,主要使用CT数据集;作者指出MRI数据集行RCV肾体积测量可获得相当准确性和可靠性,同时使患者和健康供者免受不必要辐射暴露。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

PURPOSE: This study aims to determine whether contrast-enhanced (CE)-magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is comparable to CE-computed tomography (CT) for estimation of split renal function (SRF). For this purpose, two different kidney volumetry methods, the renal cortex volumetry (RCV) and modified ellipsoid volume (MELV), are compared for both acquisition types (CT vs. MRI) with regard to accuracy and reliability, subsequently referred to as RCVCT/RCVMRI and MELVCT/MELVMRI.

METHODS: This retrospective study included 29 patients (18 men and 11 women; mean age 62.8 ± 12.4 years) who underwent CE-MRI and CE-CT of the abdomen within a period of 3 months. Two independent readers (R1/R2) performed RCV and MELV in all datasets with corresponding semiautomated software tools. RCV was performed with datasets in the arterial phase and MELV in the venous phase. Statistics were calculated using one-way ANOVA, two-tailed Student's t test, Pearson´s correlation, and Bland-Altman plots with p ≤ 0.05 being considered statistically significant.

RESULTS: In all datasets, SRF was almost identical for both volumetry methods with a mean difference of < 1%. Bland-Altman analysis comparing RCV in CT and MRI showed very good agreement for R1/R2. Interreader agreement was strong for RCVCT and good for RCVMRI (r = 0.89; r = 0.69). MELVCT/MRI interreader agreement was only moderate (r = 0.54; r = 0.50) with a high range of values. Intrareader agreement was excellent for all measurements, except MELVMRI which showed a high mean bias and range of values (RCVCT: r = 0.93, RCVMRI: r = 0.98, MELVCT: r = 0.89, MELVMRI: r = 0.54).

CONCLUSION: Renal volumetric estimates of SRF are almost as accurate and reliable with CE-MRI as with CE-CT using RCV method. In distinction, the calculation of SRF using MELV was inferior to RCV with respect to accuracy and reliability. Thus, RCV method is recommended to estimate SRF, primarily using CT datasets. However, RCV with MRI datasets for kidney volumetry allows for comparable accuracy and reliability while sparing patients and healthy donors of unnecessary radiation exposure.

来源:Abdom Radiol (NY),查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Siedek F, Haneder S, Dörner J, et al. Estimation of split renal function using different volumetric methods: inter- and intraindividual comparison between MRI and CT. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2019. PMID: 30506477. doi:10.1007/s00261-018-1857-9

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。