CT与MRI不确定肾脏肿物的标准化报告模板:SAR肾细胞癌疾病聚焦小组的协作成果
该质量改进项目通过两阶段盲法德尔菲流程,由16名来自12个机构的腹部放射学会肾细胞癌疾病聚焦小组成员参与,制定了CT与MRI不确定肾脏肿物的结构化报告模板。两轮应答率均为100%,最终13项特征获得≥80%支持作为「核心」特征,10项作为「可选」特征。
要点
- 13项「核心」特征和10项「可选」特征构成CT与MRI不确定肾脏肿物结构化报告模板。
- 特征需获≥80%成员支持方可纳入模板:<80%核心但≥80%核心或可选者列为可选。
- 第一轮中5项特征获全体一致支持为「核心」特征。
核心结论
- 制定了CT与MRI不确定肾脏肿物的结构化「核心」与「可选」报告模板,可能提高对首选和必要影像特征报告的依从性。
研究设计与样本
- 该研究为免IRB审查、迭代式、多机构质量改进项目,依据已发表的多机构调查和多机构CT与MRI放射学报告回顾数据。
- 由腹部放射学会肾细胞癌疾病聚焦小组的16名成员(来自12个机构)进行两阶段盲法德尔菲流程,制定CT与MRI不确定肾脏肿物的结构化报告模板。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 报告特征由成员评分为「核心」、「可选」或「排除」,纳入阈值为≥80%支持。
- 若<80%成员认为某特征为「核心」但≥80%认为其为「核心」或「可选」,则该特征列为「可选」;若两者均不满足则排除。
- 第一轮中50-99%受访者认为「核心」的特征(即非一致支持)及未调查的自由文本意见在第二轮评估。
- 第一轮5项特征获全体一致支持为「核心」;第二轮后13项特征获≥80%支持为「核心」,10项特征获≥80%支持为「可选」。
- 两轮应答率均为100%(16/16)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To create a succinct yet comprehensive evidence-based structured report template for indeterminate renal masses characterized at CT and MRI.
METHODS: This IRB-exempt, iterative, multi-institutional quality improvement project was informed by published data derived from a multi-institutional survey and a multi-institutional review of CT and MRI radiology reports. A two-stage blinded Delphi process by the 16-member 12-institution Society of Abdominal Radiology Disease-Focused Panel on Renal Cell Carcinoma was conducted to create a structured report template for indeterminate renal masses evaluated at CT and MRI. Individual reporting characteristics were scored by members as 'core,' 'optional,' or 'exclude.' Threshold for inclusion was ≥ 80% support. If < 80% members considered a characteristic a 'core' feature, but ≥ 80% considered it either 'core' or 'optional,' it was considered an 'optional' feature. If neither was the case, the characteristic was excluded. Free-text comments were permitted. Characteristics considered 'core' by 50-99% of respondents in Round 1 (i.e., nonunanimous support) and uninvestigated free-text comments were assessed in Round 2. Core and optional structured reporting templates were derived.
RESULTS: The response rate was 100% in Round 1 (16/16) and Round 2 (16/16). In Round 1, 5 characteristics had unanimous support as 'core' features. Following Round 2, 13 characteristics had ≥ 80% support as 'core' features, and 10 characteristics had ≥ 80% support as 'optional' features. Structured report templates were derived.
DISCUSSION: Structured 'core' and 'optional' templates for indeterminate renal masses at CT and MRI were derived, which may improve compliance with reporting preferred and essential imaging characteristics.
引用
- Davenport MS, Hu EM, Zhang A, et al. Standardized report template for indeterminate renal masses at CT and MRI: a collaborative product of the SAR Disease-Focused Panel on Renal Cell Carcinoma. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2019. PMID: 30511089. doi:10.1007/s00261-018-1851-2
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。