治疗性终止妊娠后宫内胎儿MR与死后MR成像对比:早期 gestational stage 脑异常检出一致性评价
回顾性收集53例因疑似脑异常行宫内MRI和死后MRI的胎儿,由两名儿童神经放射科医生独立及联合评估。宫内MRI与死后MRI总体一致性高(K1 0.84;K2 0.86),正确率分别为79%和45%。死后改变如脑脊液结构塌陷和扭曲现象是主要不一致原因,且与排出后时间显著相关。
要点
- 宫内MRI与死后MRI在早期 gestational age 胎儿脑异常检出上总体一致性高(Kappa 0.84–0.86)。
- 宫内MRI正确率79%,死后MRI正确率45%,以联合评估为参考标准。
- 胎儿排出后超过24小时,死后MRI对比分辨率和扭曲现象与时间显著相关。
核心结论
- 宫内MRI与死后MRI在检测早期 gestational age 胎儿脑异常方面总体一致性高,但死后MRI的正确解读需复核胎儿检查,尤其当排出后时间超过24小时。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性收集53例因疑似脑异常行宫内MRI和死后MRI的胎儿,由两名儿童神经放射科医生分别独立及联合审阅,以联合评估(宫内MRI+死后MRI)为参考标准。
关键影像表现/征象
- 死后改变如脑脊液结构塌陷和扭曲现象是宫内MRI与死后MRI主要不一致的原因。
- 死后MRI对比分辨率和扭曲现象与胎儿排出后时间显著相关(均p < 0.001)。
- 死后MRI可佐证生前诊断,仅当传统脑尸检无法进行时,可作为其有效替代。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 宫内MRI与死后MRI总体一致性:观察者1 Kappa 0.84,观察者2 Kappa 0.86。
- 以联合评估(宫内MRI+死后MRI)为参考标准,宫内MRI正确率79%,死后MRI正确率45%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 死后MRI可佐证生前诊断,仅当传统脑尸检无法进行时,可作为其有效替代。
- 解读死后MRI图像时,若检查在胎儿死亡后超过24小时进行,需谨慎。
- 对死后MRI的判读,复核胎儿检查似乎至关重要。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Fetal postmortem MR Imaging (pmMRI) has been recently used as an adjuvant tool to conventional brain autopsy after termination of pregnancy (TOP). Our purpose was to compare the diagnostic performance of intrauterine MRI (iuMRI) and pmMRI in the detection of brain anomalies in fetuses at early gestational age (GA).
MATERIAL AND METHODS: We retrospectively collected 53 fetuses who had undergone iuMRI and pmMRI for suspected brain anomalies. Two pediatric neuroradiologists reviewed iuMRI and pmMRI examinations separately and then together. We used Cohen's K to assess the agreement between pmMRI and iuMRI. Using the combined evaluation iuMRI+pMRI as the reference standard, we calculated the "correctness ratio." We used Somers' D to assess the cograduation between postmortem image quality and time elapsed after fetus expulsion.
RESULTS: Our data showed high agreement between iuMRI and pmMRI considering all the categories together, for both observers (K1 0.84; K2 0.86). The correctness ratio of iuMRI and pmMRI was 79% and 45% respectively. The major disagreements between iuMRI and pmMRI were related to postmortem changes as the collapse of liquoral structures and distorting phenomena. We also found a significant cograduation between the time elapsed from expulsion and pmMRI contrast resolution and distortive phenomena (both p < 0.001).
CONCLUSIONS: Our study demonstrates an overall high concordance between iuMRI and pmMRI in detecting fetal brain abnormalities at early GA. Nevertheless, for the correct interpretation of pmMRI, the revision of fetal examination seems to be crucial, in particular when time elapsed from expulsion is longer than 24 h.
KEY POINTS: • IuMRI and pmMRI showed overall high concordance in detecting fetal brain abnormalities at early GA. • PmMRI corroborated the antemortem diagnosis and it could be a valid alternative to conventional brain autopsy, only when the latter cannot be performed. • Some caution should be taken in interpreting pmMR images when performed after 24 h from fetal death.
引用
- Izzo G, Talenti G, Falanga G, et al. Intrauterine fetal MR versus postmortem MR imaging after therapeutic termination of pregnancy: evaluation of the concordance in the detection of brain abnormalities at early gestational stage. Eur Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30542750. doi:10.1007/s00330-018-5878-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。