人工智能对加拿大医学生放射科专业偏好的影响:一项全国性调查研究
2018年3月对加拿大全部17所医学院学生进行匿名在线调查,322名应答者中70人将放射科作为首选专业、133人列为前三选择;仅29.3%认为AI将在可预见未来取代放射科医生,但67.7%认为AI会减少对放射科医生的需求;对AI导致放射科医生被「取代」的焦虑使部分原本首选放射科的学生放弃该专业。
要点
- 67.7%的应答医学生认为AI会减少对放射科医生的需求,仅29.3%认为AI会取代放射科医生。
- 即使是将放射科作为首选的应答者中,也有48.6%因考虑放射科专业而对AI感到焦虑。
- 原本会将放射科列为第一选择的应答者中,六分之一因对AI的焦虑而不考虑放射科。
核心结论
- 对AI「取代」(而非「替代」)放射科医生的焦虑使许多医学生不愿考虑放射科专业;放射学界应教育医学生认识AI的潜在影响,以确保放射科被视为可行的长期职业选择。
研究设计与样本
- 2018年3月向加拿大全部17所医学院学生发放匿名在线调查的全国性调查研究,共322名应答者。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 322名应答者中70人将放射科作为首选专业,133人将其列为前三选择。
- 29.3%的应答者同意AI将在可预见未来取代放射科医生,67.7%同意AI会减少对放射科医生的需求。
- 首选放射科的应答者中48.6%同意AI在考虑放射科专业时引起焦虑。
- 原本会将放射科列为第一选择的应答者中六分之一因对AI的焦虑而不考虑放射科。
- 先前有重要放射科接触经历和对理解AI有高信心可降低焦虑水平。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 有兴趣的学生重视本地放射科医生、放射学会议和期刊的意见。
- 学生对「关于AI的专家意见」和「在临床前放射学课程中讨论AI」最感兴趣,以理解AI的影响。
- 作者认为放射学界应教育医学生认识AI的潜在影响,以确保放射科被视为可行的长期职业选择。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Artificial intelligence (AI) has the potential to transform the clinical practice of radiology. This study investigated Canadian medical students' perceptions of the impact of AI on radiology, and their influence on the students' preference for radiology specialty.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In March 2018, an anonymous online survey was distributed to students at all 17 Canadian medical schools.
RESULTS: Among 322 respondents, 70 students considered radiology as the top specialty choice, and 133 as among the top three choices. Only a minority (29.3%) of respondents agreed AI would replace radiologists in foreseeable future, but a majority (67.7%) agreed AI would reduce the demand for radiologists. Even among first-choice respondents, 48.6% agreed AI caused anxiety when considering the radiology specialty. Furthermore, one-sixth of respondents who would otherwise rank radiology as the first choice would not consider radiology because of the anxiety about AI. Prior significant exposure to radiology and high confidence in understanding of AI were shown to decrease the anxiety level. Interested students valued the opinions of local radiologists, radiology conferences, and journals. Students were most interested in "expert opinions on AI" and "discussing AI in preclinical radiology lectures" to understand the impact of AI.
CONCLUSION: Anxiety related to "displacement" (not "replacement") of radiologists by AI discouraged many medical students from considering the radiology specialty. The radiology community should educate medical students about the potential impact of AI, to ensure radiology is perceived as a viable long-term career choice.
引用
- Gong B, Nugent JP, Guest W, et al. Influence of Artificial Intelligence on Canadian Medical Students' Preference for Radiology Specialty: ANational Survey Study. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30424998. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.10.007
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。