多参数乳腺MRI中放射组学分析与卷积神经网络对强化病灶分类的对比
研究纳入447例患者1294个强化病灶(787恶性,507良性),比较放射组学分析(RA)与卷积神经网络(CNN)及三位乳腺放射科医师对病灶良恶性分类的诊断性能。CNN全队列训练AUC 0.88优于RA(L1正则化AUC 0.81,主成分分析AUC 0.78),但均低于放射科医师(AUC 0.98)。
要点
- CNN对乳腺MRI强化病灶良恶性分类的AUC为0.88,优于放射组学分析(AUC 0.81/0.78)。
- 放射科医师解读AUC为0.98,优于CNN和放射组学分析。
- CNN增加训练数据(全队列vs半队列)可提升性能(AUC 0.88 vs 0.83),放射组学分析无此提升。
核心结论
- 在多参数乳腺MRI中,卷积神经网络对强化病灶良恶性分类的性能优于放射组学分析,但两者均低于放射科医师;更多训练数据可进一步提升CNN性能,但对放射组学算法无此效果。
研究设计与样本
- 2011年8月至2015年8月间纳入447例患者共1294个强化病灶(787个恶性,507个良性;中位大小15 mm ± 20),由一位乳腺放射科医师手动分割病灶;放射组学分析采用L1正则化和主成分分析,CNN采用34层深度残差神经网络;所有算法也在半数病灶(n=647)上重新训练;机器判读与三位乳腺放射科医师的前瞻性判读比较;参考标准为组织学分析或随访;采用受试者工作特征曲线下面积(AUC)比较诊断性能。
诊断标准与关键数值
- CNN全队列训练AUC为0.88(95%CI:0.86,0.89),优于放射组学L1正则化AUC 0.81(95%CI:0.79,0.83;P < .001)和主成分分析AUC 0.78(95%CI:0.76,0.80;P < .001)。
- CNN全队列训练AUC 0.88优于半队列训练AUC 0.83(P = .01);放射组学L1正则化全队列AUC 0.81与半队列AUC 0.80无差异(P = .76);主成分分析全队列AUC 0.78与半队列AUC 0.78无差异(P = .93)。
- 乳腺放射科医师判读AUC为0.98(95%CI:0.96,0.99),优于CNN(P < .001)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Purpose To compare the diagnostic performance of radiomic analysis (RA) and a convolutional neural network (CNN) to radiologists for classification of contrast agent-enhancing lesions as benign or malignant at multiparametric breast MRI. Materials and Methods Between August 2011 and August 2015, 447 patients with 1294 enhancing lesions (787 malignant, 507 benign; median size, 15 mm ± 20) were evaluated. Lesions were manually segmented by one breast radiologist. RA was performed by using L1 regularization and principal component analysis. CNN used a deep residual neural network with 34 layers. All algorithms were also retrained on half the number of lesions (n = 647). Machine interpretations were compared with prospective interpretations by three breast radiologists. Standard of reference was histologic analysis or follow-up. Areas under the receiver operating curve (AUCs) were used to compare diagnostic performance. Results CNN trained on the full cohort was superior to training on the half-size cohort (AUC, 0.88 vs 0.83, respectively; P = .01), but there was no difference for RA and L1 regularization (AUC, 0.81 vs 0.80, respectively; P = .76) or RA and principal component analysis (AUC, 0.78 vs 0.78, respectively; P = .93). By using the full cohort, CNN performance (AUC, 0.88; 95% confidence interval: 0.86, 0.89) was better than RA and L1 regularization (AUC, 0.81; 95% confidence interval: 0.79, 0.83; P < .001) and RA and principal component analysis (AUC, 0.78; 95% confidence interval: 0.76, 0.80; P < .001). However, CNN was inferior to breast radiologist interpretation (AUC, 0.98; 95% confidence interval: 0.96, 0.99; P < .001). Conclusion A convolutional neural network was superior to radiomic analysis for classification of enhancing lesions as benign or malignant at multiparametric breast MRI. Both approaches were inferior to radiologists' performance; however, more training data will further improve performance of convolutional neural network, but not that of radiomics algorithms. © RSNA, 2018 Online supplemental material is available for this article.
引用
- Truhn D, Schrading S, Haarburger C, et al. Radiomic versus Convolutional Neural Networks Analysis for Classification of Contrast-enhancing Lesions at Multiparametric Breast MRI. Radiology. 2018. PMID: 30422086. doi:10.1148/radiol.2018181352
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。