动态对比增强前列腺MRI可重复性中拟合模型与动脉输入函数的选择
研究对11例疑似或确诊前列腺外周带癌的初治患者行两次前列腺DCE-MRI扫描,比较不同Tofts-Kety模型和动脉输入函数(含/不含BAT校正)提取的药代动力学参数的重复性与病理鉴别能力;结果显示两参数Tofts-Kety模型总体重复性最佳,kep重复性优于Ktrans,Ktrans和kep区分健康与病变组织高度显著,ve重复性高但不能区分组织类型。
要点
- 两参数Tofts-Kety模型总体重复性评分最佳,拟合优度更支持含BAT校正的四参数扩展模型。
- 肿瘤可疑ROI最佳重复性系数:kep为63%、ve为28%、Ktrans为83%。
- Ktrans和kep区分组织高度显著(P<10⁻⁵),ve未达显著(P=0.11)。
核心结论
- 使用直接从血液信号测量的动脉输入函数时,参数kep比Ktrans更具可重复性;Ktrans和kep在所有病例中均高度区分健康与病变组织,ve重复性高但不能区分两种组织类型。
研究设计与样本
- 对11例疑似或确诊前列腺外周带癌的初治患者在两周内行两次前列腺DCE-MRI扫描,分割肿瘤可疑与正常表现的外周带ROI,采用不同Tofts-Kety模型和不同动脉输入函数(含/不含BAT校正)提取Ktrans、ve、kep并计算重复性系数。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 肿瘤可疑ROI最佳%RC:kep为63%,ve为28%,Ktrans为83%。
- 组织鉴别最佳P值:kep和Ktrans均为P<10⁻⁵,ve为P=0.11。
- 拟合优度标准支持含BAT校正的四参数扩展Tofts-Kety模型,但两参数Tofts-Kety模型总体重复性最佳。
- 向模型加入BAT校正未改善重复性。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Analysis of dynamic contrast-enhanced (DCE) magnetic resonance imaging is notable for the variability of calculated parameters. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the level of measurement variability and error/variability due to modeling in DCE magnetic resonance imaging parameters.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two prostate DCE scans were performed on 11 treatment-naïve patients with suspected or confirmed prostate peripheral zone cancer within an interval of less than two weeks. Tumor-suspicious and normal-appearing regions of interest (ROI) in the prostate peripheral zone were segmented. Different Tofts-Kety based models and different arterial input functions, with and without bolus arrival time (BAT) correction, were used to extract pharmacokinetic parameters. The percent repeatability coefficient (%RC) of fitted model parameters Ktrans, ve, and kep was calculated. Paired t-tests comparing parameters in tumor-suspicious ROIs and in normal-appearing tissue evaluated each parameter's sensitivity to pathology.
RESULTS: Although goodness-of-fit criteria favored the four-parameter extended Tofts-Kety model with the BAT correction included, the simplest two-parameter Tofts-Kety model overall yielded the best repeatability scores. The best %RC in the tumor-suspicious ROI was 63% for kep, 28% for ve, and 83% for Ktrans . The best p values for discrimination between tissues were p <10-5 for kep and Ktrans, and p = 0.11 for ve. Addition of the BAT correction to the models did not improve repeatability.
CONCLUSION: The parameter kep, using an arterial input functions directly measured from blood signals, was more repeatable than Ktrans. Both Ktrans and kep values were highly discriminatory between healthy and diseased tissues in all cases. The parameter ve had high repeatability but could not distinguish the two tissue types.
引用
- Peled S, Vangel M, Kikinis R, et al. Selection of Fitting Model and Arterial Input Function for Repeatability in Dynamic Contrast-Enhanced Prostate MRI. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30467073. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.10.018
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。