放射科医生使用CT检测肺癌的表现
30名放射科医生阅读60例胸部CT(30例经手术或活检证实肺癌,30例无癌),平均敏感度0.749、特异度0.81、AUC 0.846;癌症专科中心与非专科中心放射科医生的AUC均为0.846,前者敏感度较高(0.80 vs 0.719)但特异度较低(0.794 vs 0.82),作者认为这归因于专科中心医生阅片时较少保守。
要点
- 放射科医生检测肺癌的平均敏感度0.749、特异度0.81、AUC 0.846。
- 癌症专科中心医生敏感度0.80、特异度0.794;非专科中心医生敏感度0.719、特异度0.82。
- 两组AUC均为0.846,作者认为判别能力相似,敏感度/特异度差异源于阅片保守程度不同。
核心结论
- 放射科医生的检测效能与其他研究相当;专科与非专科癌症中心放射科医生的AUC相似,提示判别能力相似,专科中心医生敏感度较高、特异度较低可归因于其阅片时较少保守。
研究设计与样本
- 30名放射科医生阅读60例胸部CT,其中30例为手术或活检证实的肺癌、30例为无癌病例;癌症病例由四位专家放射科医生定位恶性肺结节进行验证;通过计算敏感度、定位敏感度、特异度和ROC曲线下面积(AUC)评估读者表现,并从每位读者的估计ROC曲线计算固定特异度0.794下的敏感度。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 全体放射科医生平均敏感度0.749、固定特异度0.794下的敏感度0.744、定位敏感度0.666、特异度0.81、AUC 0.846;癌症专科中心与非专科中心放射科医生分别为:敏感度0.80 vs 0.719,固定特异度0.794下的敏感度0.752 vs 0.740,定位敏感度0.712 vs 0.637,特异度0.794 vs 0.82,AUC 0.846 vs 0.846。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为专科与非专科癌症中心放射科医生判别能力相似,专科中心医生敏感度较高、特异度较低可归因于其阅片时较少保守。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
AIM: To measure the level of radiologists' performance in lung cancer detection, and to explore radiologists' performance in cancer specialised and non-specialised centres.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thirty radiologists read 60 chest computed tomography (CT) examinations. Thirty cases had surgically or biopsy-proven lung cancer and 30 were cancer-free cases. The cancer cases were validated by four expert radiologists who located the malignant lung nodules. Reader performance was evaluated by calculating sensitivity, location sensitivity, specificity, and area under the receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve (AUC). In addition, sensitivity at fixed specificity (0.794) was computed from each reader's estimated ROC curve.
RESULTS: The radiologists had a mean sensitivity of 0.749, sensitivity at fixed specificity of 0.744, location sensitivity of 0.666, specificity of 0.81 and AUC of 0.846. Radiologists in the specialised and non-specialised cancer centres had the following (specialised, non-specialised) pairs of values: sensitivity=(0.80, 0.719); sensitivity for fixed 0.794 specificity=(0.752, 0.740); location sensitivity=(0.712, 0.637); specificity=(0.794, 0.82) and AUC=(0.846, 0.846).
CONCLUSION: The efficacy of radiologists was comparable to other studies. Furthermore, AUC outcomes were similar for specialised and non-specialised cancer centre radiologists, suggesting they have similar discriminatory ability and that the higher sensitivity and lower specificity for specialised-centre radiologists can be attributed to them being less conservative in interpreting case images.
引用
- Al Mohammad B, Hillis SL, Reed W, et al. Radiologist performance in the detection of lung cancer using CT. Clin Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30470412. doi:10.1016/j.crad.2018.10.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。