经中脑导水管的相位对比成像能否预测疑似成人脑积水患者腰大池脑脊液引流或分流手术的结局
回顾性分析185例疑似慢性成人脑积水患者的相位对比MR成像,评估中脑导水管脑脊液每搏输出量和流率对诊断性腰椎穿刺/腰大池引流及分流手术临床反应的预测价值。结果显示引流量和流率在引流有效者与无效者、分流有效者与无效者之间均存在显著重叠,单独用其预测反应效果差;腰大池引流后定量临床指标对分流反应的预测更好。结论提示不应单独依据导水管相位对比MR成像结果选择诊断性或治疗性脑脊液分流患者。
要点
- 导水管每搏输出量和流率在腰大池引流有效与无效者间存在重叠,单独预测反应效果差。
- 导水管每搏输出量和流率在分流手术有效与无效者间也存在重叠,单独预测反应效果差。
- 腰大池引流后的定量临床指标对分流手术反应的预测优于导水管相位对比MR成像。
核心结论
- 本研究提示不应单独使用经中脑导水管的相位对比MR成像结果来选择诊断性或治疗性脑脊液分流患者。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究纳入185例疑似慢性成人脑积水患者,使用脑脊液流动软件包分析其相位对比MR成像。
- 分流手术决策仅基于临床评估,未参考定量相位对比MR成像结果。
- 采用Tinetti测试、起立行走计时测试和简易精神状态检查等定量测试,以及步态、泌尿和认知症状改善的定性指标,记录腰椎穿刺/腰大池引流前后和分流手术前后的反应。
- 将相位对比MR成像的定量分析与临床结局指标进行比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 脑脊液每搏输出量和流率在腰椎穿刺/腰大池引流有效者与无效者之间存在重叠。
- 脑脊液每搏输出量和流率在分流手术有效者与无效者之间也存在显著重叠。
- 单独以导水管每搏输出量或流率预测腰椎穿刺/腰大池引流和分流手术反应的效果差。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片时不应仅凭导水管相位对比MR成像的每搏输出量或流率结果建议或排除诊断性/治疗性脑脊液分流。
- 腰大池引流后的定量临床指标可能比导水管相位对比MR成像更好地预测分流手术反应。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Radiologic imaging plays a key role in diagnosing chronic adult hydrocephalus, but its role in predicting prognosis is still controversial. We sought to evaluate the effectiveness of cardiac-gated phase-contrast MR imaging through the cerebral aqueduct in predicting the clinical response to diagnostic lumbar puncture/lumbar drainage and shunt surgery in suspected adult hydrocephalus.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, the phase-contrast MR imaging of 185 patients with suspected chronic adult hydrocephalus was evaluated using the CSF Flow software package. Decision-making for shunt placement was performed in this cohort on the basis of clinical assessment alone without the availability of quantitative phase-contrast MR imaging results. We recorded the response to lumbar puncture or lumbar drainage and shunt surgery using quantitative tests such as the Tinetti Test, the Timed Up and Go, and the Mini-Mental State Examination and qualitative measures of gait, urinary, and cognitive symptom improvement before and after lumbar puncture/lumbar drainage and shunt surgery. Quantitative analysis of phase-contrast MR imaging was compared with clinical outcome measures.
RESULTS: Both CSF stroke volume and flow rate overlapped between lumbar puncture/lumbar drainage responders and nonresponders. There was also a significant overlap between shunt responders and nonresponders. Aqueductal stroke volume or flow rate alone was a poor predictor of lumbar puncture/lumbar drainage and shunt surgery response. Quantitative clinical measures after lumbar puncture/lumbar drainage were better predictors of shunt response.
CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that the results of phase-contrast MR imaging through the cerebral aqueduct alone should not be used to select patients for diagnostic or therapeutic CSF diversion.
引用
- Blitz AM, Shin J, Balédent O, et al. Does Phase-Contrast Imaging through the Cerebral Aqueduct Predict the Outcome of Lumbar CSF Drainage or Shunt Surgery in Patients with Suspected Adult Hydrocephalus? AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2018. PMID: 30467214. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A5857
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。