血友病关节肌肉骨骼超声结构异常定量评估的关节组织活动与损伤检查方法的开发与信度研究
研究开发了名为关节组织活动与损伤检查(JADE)的定量算法,用于肌肉骨骼超声量化血友病关节异常,并对31例血友病患者进行约600次关节检查和约6000幅图像序列评估。有肌肉骨骼超声经验的血友病医师在组织测量上显示优秀的组内和组间信度(ICC 0.94-0.96),无经验者在测量上组间信度优秀(ICC 0.96),但解剖标志识别仅为中等一致(Fleiss κ 0.58)。结论认为JADE方案用于量化血友病关节内异常似乎可行。
要点
- 有经验医师的组织测量组内和组间信度优秀(ICC 0.94-0.96),解剖标志识别一致性良好至优秀(Fleiss κ 0.87-0.94)。
- 无经验医师的组织测量组间信度优秀(ICC 0.96),但解剖标志识别一致性仅为中等(Fleiss κ 0.58)。
- 操作者间信度在测量和解剖标志识别上均优秀(ICC 0.90;Fleiss κ 1.0)。
核心结论
- JADE方案用于量化血友病关节内异常似乎可行,有肌肉骨骼超声经验的血友病医师显示高的组内、组间和操作者间信度,支持JADE作为临床管理和研究的方案。
研究设计与样本
- 对31例血友病患者进行为期2年的序列肌肉骨骼超声检查(约600次关节检查和约6000幅图像);基于病理谱采用名义组技术开发JADE定量算法,用于软组织和骨软骨测量(包括能量多普勒);8名有肌肉骨骼超声经验的血友病医师对86幅有关节病变图像进行解剖标志识别和组织测量,1个月后重复;23名无经验医师进行类似评估;6名有经验医师各自采集3个血友病关节病变关节的图像并进行JADE评估以建立操作者间信度;一名放射科医师和一名肌肉骨骼超声技师担任裁决者;统计分析采用组内相关系数(ICC)、Fleiss κ和Cohen κ。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 有经验医师组织测量的组内和组间信度ICC为0.94-0.96。
- 有经验医师解剖标志识别的Fleiss κ为0.87-0.94。
- 操作者间信度测量ICC为0.90,解剖标志识别Fleiss κ为1.0。
- 无经验医师组织测量组间信度ICC为0.96,解剖标志识别Fleiss κ为0.58。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 有肌肉骨骼超声经验的血友病医师使用JADE方案进行组织测量和解剖标志识别可获得高信度。
- 无经验医师使用JADE进行组织测量信度优秀,但解剖标志识别一致性中等。
- 与裁决者的一致性大多为良好至优秀。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Musculoskeletal ultrasound (US) is used increasingly to examine hemophilic arthropathy. However, quantitative algorithms to document findings are lacking. We developed and sought to validate a protocol quantifying hemophilic joint abnormalities.
METHODS: Thirty-one patients with hemophilia were examined serially for 2 years with musculoskeletal US (≈600 joint examinations and ≈6000 images). Based on the spectrum of pathologies, a quantitative algorithm, named Joint Tissue Activity and Damage Examination (JADE), was developed for soft tissue and osteochondral measurements, including power Doppler, using nominal group techniques. To study intra- and inter-rater reliability, 8 musculoskeletal US-experienced hemophilia providers performed anatomic landmark recognition and tissue measurements on 86 images with arthropathic changes, with repetition 1 month later. Twenty-three musculoskeletal US-inexperienced providers performed similar assessments. Inter-operator reliability was established by 6 musculoskeletal US-experienced hemophilia providers, each acquiring images and JADE assessments of 3 hemophilic arthropathic joints. A radiologist and musculoskeletal sonographer functioned as adjudicators. The statistical analysis was performed with the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), Fleiss κ, and Cohen κ where appropriate.
RESULTS: The musculoskeletal US-experienced providers showed excellent intra-and inter-rater reliability for tissue measurements (ICCs, 0.94-0.96). Agreement was good to excellent for landmark recognition (Fleiss κ, 0.87-0.94). Inter-operator reliability was excellent for measurements and landmark recognition (ICC, 0.90; Fleiss κ, 1.0). Agreement with adjudicators was mostly good to excellent. Musculoskeletal US-inexperienced providers showed excellent inter-rater reliability for measurements (ICC, 0.96) and moderate agreement for landmark recognition (Fleiss κ, 0.58).
CONCLUSIONS: The JADE protocol appears feasible for quantifying hemophilic intra-articular abnormalities. Musculoskeletal US-trained hemophilia providers showed high intra-rater, inter-rater, and inter-operator reliability, supporting JADE as a protocol for clinical management and research.
引用
- Volland LM, Zhou JY, Barnes RFW, et al. Development and Reliability of the Joint Tissue Activity and Damage Examination for Quantitation of Structural Abnormalities by Musculoskeletal Ultrasound in Hemophilic Joints. J Ultrasound Med. 2018. PMID: 30371941. doi:10.1002/jum.14846
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。