乳腺密度告知法实施前后补充性乳腺癌筛查的种族间差异
研究纳入美国密歇根州2764名非裔美国女性和691名欧裔美国女性,比较乳腺密度告知法实施前后乳腺X线筛查阴性或良性者的补充筛查(MRI、超声或断层合成)情况。结果显示法律实施后补充筛查从0.14%增至0.7%(约5倍),主要由非裔美国女性增加驱动;法律实施后乳腺密度对补充筛查的预测作用更强,且欧裔美国女性中5年乳腺癌风险与补充筛查的关联由法律实施前的正相关转为负相关。
要点
- 乳腺密度告知法实施后,筛查阴性女性的补充筛查从0.14%增至0.7%,约增加5倍。
- 补充筛查的增加主要由非裔美国女性驱动。
- 法律实施后乳腺密度对补充筛查的预测作用更强,法律实施后欧裔美国女性中5年乳腺癌风险与补充筛查呈负相关。
核心结论
- 乳腺密度告知法的通过可能特别激励了非裔美国女性的补充筛查,但降低了乳腺癌风险在补充筛查决策中的考量。
研究设计与样本
- 研究样本为2764名非裔美国女性和691名欧裔美国女性,均有乳腺X线筛查阴性或良性结果及密歇根州乳腺密度告知法实施前后的数据,补充筛查定义为筛查乳腺X线后6个月内的MRI、超声或断层合成。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 补充筛查定义为筛查乳腺X线后6个月内进行的MRI、超声或断层合成。
- 法律实施后补充筛查从0.14%增至0.7%,约增加5倍。
- 亚组分析(n=250)中,法律实施前欧裔美国女性5年乳腺癌风险与补充筛查正相关,法律实施后为负相关;非裔美国女性法律实施前后5年风险均与补充筛查无关联。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
Guidelines recommend supplemental breast cancer screening for women at increased breast cancer risk; however, the passage of breast density notification laws may lead to supplemental screening that is incongruent with women's risk. We examined supplemental screening (ie, MRI, ultrasound, or tomosynthesis within 6 months of screening mammogram) among a sample of 2,764 African American (AA) and 691 European American (EA) women with negative or benign screening mammograms for whom we had data from both before and after implementation of breast density notification laws in the state of Michigan. Results indicated a 5-fold increase (from 0.14% to 0.7% of women) in supplemental screening among screen-negative women after passage of the law, driven in large part by an increase in supplemental screening among AA women. Breast density was more predictive of supplemental screening and had a marginally greater explanatory role in between-race differences in supplemental screening after passage of the law. Subgroup analyses (n = 250) indicated that whereas 5-year breast cancer risk was positively associated with supplemental screening before the law and negatively associated after the law for EA women, 5-year risk was not associated with supplemental screening either before or after passage of the law for AA women. Our findings suggest that whereas passage of the breast density notification laws may have motivated supplemental screening among AA women in particular, it lessened the consideration of breast cancer risk in supplemental screening decision making.
引用
- Manning M, Albrecht TL, O'Neill S, et al. Between-Race Differences in Supplemental Breast Cancer Screening Before and After Breast Density Notification Law. J Am Coll Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30342908. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2018.08.020
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。