文献速递妇产影像泌尿生殖US

前瞻性外部验证IOTA三步策略鉴别与分类附件肿物的诊断性能,并回顾性评估采用简单规则风险模型的替代两步策略

Prospective external validation of IOTA three-step strategy for characterizing and classifying adnexal masses and retrospective assessment of alternative two-step strategy using simple-rules risk.
PubMed 文献 · Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol · 2019-01-01

在两所大学医院前瞻性纳入2015年9月至2017年8月连续诊断的附件肿物患者283例,由非专家超声医师执行IOTA三步策略的前两步。三步策略总体敏感度95.2%、特异度97.7%、LR+ 42.1、LR- 0.05、准确率97.2%。回顾性评估以简单规则风险(SRR)替代第二步的替代两步策略,敏感度98.4%、特异度63.8%。

要点

  • 非专家超声医师执行IOTA三步策略,238/283(84.1%)肿物可在前两步完成分类。
  • 三步策略总体敏感度95.2%、特异度97.7%、LR+ 42.1、LR- 0.05、准确率97.2%。
  • 以SRR替代第二步的替代两步策略敏感度98.4%、特异度63.8%,但会使210例女性接受手术治疗。

核心结论

  • 非专家超声医师使用IOTA三步策略鉴别附件肿物良恶性具有高准确率;第二步采用SRR计算器的替代策略可能通过减少手术干预并提高敏感度来改善诊断性能。

研究设计与样本

  • 前瞻性观察性研究,2015年9月至2017年8月在两所大学医院连续纳入283例附件肿物患者,中位年龄48岁(范围18-90岁)。

关键影像表现/征象

  • 简单描述语可应用于126个(44.5%)肿物。
  • 剩余157个病灶中112个(39.6%)可用简单规则(SR)分类,故238个(84.1%)肿物由非专家在前两步完成分类。
  • 剩余45个(15.9%)肿物均由专家超声医师完成分类。
  • 替代两步策略中,未用简单描述语分类的157个病灶里,低、中、高风险分别为42、38和77个。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • IOTA三步策略总体敏感度95.2%、特异度97.7%、LR+ 42.1、LR- 0.05、准确率97.2%。
  • 替代两步策略(第二步用SRR,中或高风险假定手术)敏感度98.4%、特异度63.8%。
  • 参考标准为手术组织学诊断,或期待管理病例至少12个月随访;期待管理的全部肿物视为良性。
  • 216例(76.3%)接受手术(154个良性、62个恶性),67例(23.7%)期待管理并超声随访至少12个月。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 非专家超声医师可先以简单描述语分类附件肿物,无法分类者再用简单规则(SR),仍无法分类者由专家主观评估。
  • 非专家在前两步可分类84.1%的肿物,提示该流程可减少对专家评估的依赖。
  • SRR替代第二步时敏感度提高但特异度降低,且会使210例女性接受手术治疗。

局限性

  • 替代两步策略为回顾性评估。
  • 作者结论使用「might improve」表述,提示该替代策略的改善作用尚需进一步验证。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

OBJECTIVES: To perform an external validation of the diagnostic performance of the three-step strategy proposed by the International Ovarian Tumor Analysis (IOTA) group for classifying adnexal masses as benign or malignant, when ultrasound is performed by non-expert sonographers in the first two steps. The second objective was to assess the diagnostic performance of an alternative strategy using simple-rules risk (SRR), instead of simple rules (SR), in the second step.

METHODS: This was a prospective observational study conducted at two university hospitals, from September 2015 to August 2017, of consecutive patients diagnosed with an adnexal mass. All women were evaluated by ultrasound using the IOTA three-step strategy. Non-expert sonographers performed the first step (use of simple descriptors to classify the masses) and the second step (use of SR if the mass could not be classified in the first step); masses that could not be classified in the first two steps were categorized by an expert sonographer based on their subjective assessment (third step). The reference standard was histological diagnosis in patients who underwent surgery or at least 12 months of follow-up in cases managed expectantly. The sensitivity, specificity, positive (LR+) and negative (LR-) likelihood ratios and overall accuracy of the IOTA three-step strategy were estimated. Furthermore, we evaluated retrospectively an alternative two-step strategy using SRR in the second step to categorize the masses not classifiable with simple descriptors, classifying the lesions as being of low, intermediate or high risk for malignancy. The diagnostic performance of this strategy was estimated by calculating its sensitivity and specificity, assuming surgical intervention for intermediate- or high-risk lesions.

RESULTS: The study included 283 patients (median age, 48 (range, 18-90) years), of whom 165 (58.3%) were premenopausal and 118 (41.7%) postmenopausal. Two hundred and sixteen (76.3%) women underwent surgery (154 benign and 62 malignant masses) and 67 (23.7%) were managed expectantly with serial ultrasound follow-up for at least 12 months. All expectantly managed masses were considered benign because no sonographic changes suggestive of malignancy were observed during follow-up. Simple descriptors could be applied in 126 (44.5%) masses. Of the remaining 157 lesions, 112 (39.6%) could be characterized using SR. Therefore, 238 (84.1%) masses could be classified by non-expert sonographers in the first two steps. Of the remaining 45 (15.9%) masses, all could be classified by an expert sonographer. Overall sensitivity, specificity, LR+ and LR- of the IOTA three-step strategy were 95.2%, 97.7%, 42.1 and 0.05, respectively. The diagnostic accuracy was 97.2%. Following the two-step strategy using SRR in the second step, of the 157 lesions not classified with simple descriptors, 42, 38 and 77 presented low, intermediate or high risk for malignancy, respectively. Based on this method, 210 women would have undergone surgical treatment. The sensitivity and specificity of this two-step strategy were 98.4% and 63.8%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS: The IOTA three-step strategy shows high accuracy for discriminating between benign and malignant adnexal lesions when used by non-expert sonographers. An alternative strategy using the SRR calculator in the second step might improve on this diagnostic performance by decreasing the number of surgical interventions and increasing sensitivity. Copyright © 2018 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.

来源:Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Hidalgo JJ, Ros F, Aubá M, et al. Prospective external validation of IOTA three-step strategy for characterizing and classifying adnexal masses and retrospective assessment of alternative two-step strategy using simple-rules risk. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 30353585. doi:10.1002/uog.20163

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。