美国内科、儿科及内科-儿科住院医师项目中床旁超声教育的普及率与范围
2016年1月至6月对美国685名住院医师项目主任进行15项在线问卷调查,回复率19.2%。仅31.5%的项目有正式床旁超声课程,12.4%的项目完全无超声培训;内科和内科-儿科正式课程率分别为37.5%和43.5%,儿科仅12.4%且有27.3%无任何床旁超声培训。缺乏受训师资/讲师(70.4%)是主要原因。
要点
- 仅31.5%的住院医师项目报告设有正式床旁超声课程,12.4%的项目完全无超声培训。
- 儿科项目床旁超声培训最有限:正式课程率12.4%,27.3%无任何床旁超声培训。
- 缺乏受训师资/讲师(70.4%)是项目主任报告的最常见原因。
核心结论
- 不到一半的内科住院医师会在设有床旁超声课程的项目中接受培训,儿科床旁超声培训更为有限;缺乏受训师资或讲师是缺乏床旁超声教育的主要原因。
研究设计与样本
- 2016年1月至6月对685名内科、儿科及内科-儿科住院医师项目主任进行15项在线问卷调查,回复率19.2%。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 全体受访项目中仅31.5%报告有正式床旁超声课程,12.4%的项目完全无超声培训。
- 内科受访项目(n=64)正式床旁超声课程率为37.5%。
- 内科-儿科受访项目(n=24)正式床旁超声课程率为43.5%。
- 儿科受访项目(n=24)正式课程率仅12.4%,27.3%的项目完全无床旁超声培训。
- 缺乏正式床旁超声课程的原因:缺乏受训师资/讲师70.4%、缺乏管理学会指南/标准44.4%、缺乏必要技术33.3%。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: The purpose of this study was to determine the prevalence and scope of point-of-care ultrasound (US) education in internal medicine, pediatric, and medicine-pediatric residency programs nationwide.
METHODS: Program directors were surveyed between January and June 2016 with a 15-item online questionnaire to assess the state of point-of-care US training in their programs. The survey aimed to identify whether programs had an established point-of-care US curriculum and, if not, what reasons may have existed for a lack of point-of-care US training in their programs.
RESULTS: The survey was distributed to 685 program directors, and the response rate was 19.2%. Only 31.5% of respondents reported having a formal point-of-care US curriculum in their program, and in 12.4% of programs, there was no US training at all. The presence of point-of-care US training as reported by internal medicine (n = 64) and medicine-pediatric (n = 24) respondents showed formal point-of-care US curriculum rates of 37.5% and 43.5%, respectively. Pediatric programs (n = 24) reported limited point-of-care US training, with formal curriculum in only 12.4% of programs and 27.3% having no point-of-care US training at all. The most common reasons for lack of a point-of-care US curriculum among program directors were lack of trained faculty/instructors (70.4%), lack of guidelines/standards by governing societies (44.4%), and lack of the necessary technology (33.3%).
CONCLUSIONS: Less than half of residents with internal medicine training will have trained at a program with a point-of-care US curriculum, and point-of-care US training in pediatrics is even more limited. The major reason for the lack of point-of-care US education is a lack of trained faculty or instructors.
引用
- Reaume M, Siuba M, Wagner M, et al. Prevalence and Scope of Point-of-Care Ultrasound Education in Internal Medicine, Pediatric, and Medicine-Pediatric Residency Programs in the United States. J Ultrasound Med. 2018. PMID: 30255947. doi:10.1002/jum.14821
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。