二维与三维经阴道超声诊断子宫腺肌症的阅片者间一致性
这项前瞻性研究纳入96例有月经过多或经期疼痛、拟行子宫切除或子宫内膜经宫颈切除术的绝经前妇女,比较实时二维与离线三维经阴道超声诊断子宫腺肌症的阅片者间一致性。二维超声的Cohen κ为0.69(好),三维超声为0.21(差),两者差异有统计学意义(P < .05);二维一致性随时间改善,三维在专家采集的容积中略好(κ = 0.40)。
要点
- 实时二维经阴道超声采用标准化模式识别诊断子宫腺肌症,专家与非专家阅片者间一致性为好(κ = 0.69)。
- 离线三维经阴道超声诊断子宫腺肌症的阅片者间一致性差(κ = 0.21),结合带测量未提高一致性。
- 二维超声中最可重复的征象为无回声腔隙(κ = 0.52),三维中最可重复的征象为结合带不规则(κ = 0.27)。
核心结论
- 实时二维经阴道超声采用标准化模式识别可能使专家与非专家阅片者诊断子宫腺肌症达到好的一致性;离线三维经阴道超声可重复性较低,结合带测量未改善阅片者间一致性。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究纳入96例有月经过多、经期疼痛或两者兼有且拟行子宫切除或子宫内膜经宫颈切除术的绝经前妇女;所有妇女接受实时二维经阴道超声,随后由一名专家阅片者和一名非专家阅片者以盲于二维结果的方式离线判读三维经阴道超声;三维容积在二维检查时采集,专家阅片者报告全部192个三维容积的图像质量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 以标准化模式识别和结合带测量为诊断基础;二维经阴道超声诊断子宫腺肌症的阅片者间一致性κ = 0.69(好),三维经阴道超声κ = 0.21(差),两者比较P < .05;专家采集的三维容积κ = 0.40且图像质量更好(P < .05);二维最可重复征象为无回声腔隙(κ = 0.52),三维最可重复征象为结合带不规则(κ = 0.27)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 实时二维经阴道超声采用标准化模式识别可能使专家与非专家阅片者诊断子宫腺肌症达到好的一致性;离线三维经阴道超声可重复性较低,结合带测量未改善阅片者间一致性;三维一致性低可能与经验不足和非专家采集三维容积图像质量低有关。
局限性
- 三维经阴道超声阅片者间一致性低可能与经验不足有关。
- 三维经阴道超声阅片者间一致性低可能与低图像质量有关,非专家采集的三维容积图像质量较低。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To assess the inter-rater agreement of 2-dimensional (2D) and 3-dimensional (3D) transvaginal ultrasonography (TVUS) in the diagnosis of adenomyosis.
METHODS: This prospective study included premenopausal women (n = 96) with heavy menstrual bleeding, menstrual pain, or both who were scheduled for hysterectomy or transcervical resection of the endometrium. All women underwent real-time 2D TVUS and subsequently offline 3D TVUS, which was blinded to 2D TVUS, by a single expert rater and a single nonexpert rater for the diagnosis of adenomyosis based on standardized pattern recognition and junctional zone measurements. Three-dimensional TVUS was done on a computer with 3D volumes recorded during 2D TVUS by both raters. The expert rater reported the image quality of all 3D volumes (n = 192). Inter-rater agreement (Cohen's κ) was assessed for both techniques, and the improvement over time was assessed for 2D TVUS.
RESULTS: Diagnosis of adenomyosis showed good (κ = 0.69) and poor (κ = 0.21) inter-rater agreement with 2D and 3D TVUS, respectively (P < .05). The agreement with 2D TVUS improved over time. The agreement with 3D TVUS was slightly better for expert-recorded 3D volumes (κ = 0.40), which also had better image quality (P < .05). The most reproducible 2D and 3D features were anechoic lacunae (κ = 0.52) and junctional zone irregularity (κ = 0.27), respectively.
CONCLUSIONS: Standardized pattern recognition during real-time 2D TVUS may result in good agreement between expert and nonexpert raters for the diagnosis of adenomyosis. Offline 3D TVUS is less reproducible, and junctional zone measurements do not improve the inter-rater agreement. The low inter-rater agreement may be related to a lack of experience and low image quality of nonexpert-recorded 3D volumes.
引用
- Rasmussen CK, Hansen ES, Dueholm M, et al. Inter-rater agreement in the diagnosis of adenomyosis by 2- and 3-dimensional transvaginal ultrasonography. J Ultrasound Med. 2018. PMID: 30182497. doi:10.1002/jum.14735
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。