期刊俱乐部:肝胆胰影像二次意见咨询——二次阅片是否有价值?
该回顾性研究分析了2014年1月至2015年12月间480例连续肝胆胰疾病患者的院外CT和MRI会诊报告,由两位腹部放射科医生独立比较初始报告与会诊报告。结果显示27-28%的病例存在重大差异,共识复核时升至32%,差异主要源于良恶性判断(49%)和分期准确性(15%)。
要点
- 肝胆胰影像二次意见会诊中约27-28%存在重大差异,共识复核升至32%。
- 重大差异中良恶性判断占49%,分期准确性占15%。
- 16%的病例存在影像局限性,常因扫描方案不足或图像质量差。
核心结论
- 肝胆胰影像会诊中约三分之一病例存在直接影响临床管理的解读差异,三级医疗机构的二次意见影像会诊可频繁影响管理。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性图表审查,纳入2014年1月至2015年12月间480例连续CT和MRI会诊报告,初始报告均来自院外机构,由两位腹部放射科医生独立审阅并比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 重大差异定义为检出或解读异常方面的主要不同,临床重要性定义为直接改变患者管理的发现或解读变化。
- 重大差异率:两位阅片者各自判读时为27-28%,共识复核时升至32%。
- 差异来源:良恶性判断占49%,分期准确性占15%。
- 阅片者间分类一致性为中等(加权kappa值0.49)。
- 16%的病例描述了影像局限性,常因扫描方案不足或图像质量差。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 对院外肝胆胰CT和MRI进行二次意见阅片时,应重评估病灶良恶性及分期,这两类差异最常见。
- 会诊报告中需注明因扫描方案不足或图像质量差导致的影像局限性(16%的病例存在)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: Tertiary care practices increasingly provide second-opinion consultations on reports from outside practices or institutions. This practice of providing a second opinion has been studied in a variety of subspecialties; however, its potential effect on the management of hepatopancreaticobiliary (HPB) disease is not known. The purpose of this study was to assess the rate of significant discrepancies between the initial report and the consultation report, the source of discrepancies, and the frequency of repeat imaging recommendations.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: Retrospective chart review was performed for 480 consecutive CT and MRI consultation reports interpreted between January 2014 and December 2015 for patients with HPB diseases whose initial CT and MRI reports were generated at outside facilities. The initial report and the consultation report were independently reviewed and compared by two abdominal radiologists. Discrepancies between the initial report and the consultation report were divided into minor and major differences in the detection or interpretation of abnormalities. Clinical importance was defined as a change in a finding or interpretation that directly impacted management of the patient.
RESULTS: A major discrepancy between the reports was identified in 27-28% of cases split evenly between detection and interpretation of abnormalities. Interreader agreement for categorization was moderate (weighted kappa value, 0.49). In consensus review, the rate of a major discrepancy occurring increased to 32%. Common sources of discrepancy were interpretation of findings as malignant versus benign (49% of cases) and accuracy of staging (15% of cases). Imaging limitations were described in 16% of cases, commonly as a result of an insufficient protocol or poor image quality.
CONCLUSION: Discrepancies in interpretation resulting in direct implications for clinical management are seen in almost one-third of HPB consultation cases. Second-opinion imaging consultation in the tertiary care setting can frequently impact management.
引用
- Shetty AS, Mittal A, Salter A, et al. JOURNAL CLUB: Hepatopancreaticobiliary Imaging Second-Opinion Consultations: Is There Value in the Second Reading? AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2018. PMID: 30247982. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.19452
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。