自动化ASPECT评分:Frontier ASPECT Score软件与Brainomix软件的比较
本研究回顾性分析150例疑似急性大脑中动脉缺血患者的平扫脑CT,比较Frontier与Brainomix两套计算机辅助诊断系统与两名资深放射科医生的ASPECTS评分。Brainomix与放射科医生及专家共识评分高度相关,而Frontier仅呈低至中度相关。
要点
- Brainomix自动ASPECTS评分与放射科医生及专家共识高度相关(r=0.714至0.841)。
- Frontier自动ASPECTS评分与放射科医生、专家共识及Brainomix仅低至中度相关(r=0.471至0.680)。
- Brainomix_2的Bland-Altman平均ASPECTS差值为-0.2(SD=1.15),Frontier_2为1.2(SD=1.76)。
核心结论
- 两名放射科医生、专家共识评分与Brainomix之间ASPECTS评分一致性高,但与Frontier仅低至中度一致。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析150例疑似急性大脑中动脉缺血患者的非增强脑CT,由两名资深放射科医生分别及共识进行ASPECTS评分,并与Frontier和Brainomix全自动(Frontier_1、Brainomix_1)及校正患侧大脑半球后的读数(Frontier_2、Brainomix_2)比较;统计采用组内相关系数和Bland-Altman分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- Brainomix_1、Brainomix_2、两名放射科医生及专家共识评分的ASPECTS评分高度相关(r=0.714至0.841;均p<0.001)。
- Frontier_1和Frontier_2与两名放射科医生、专家共识及Brainomix的相关性仅低或中度(r=0.471至0.680;均p<0.001)。
- Bland-Altman分析显示Brainomix_2的平均ASPECTS差值=-0.2(SD=1.15),Frontier_2的平均ASPECTS差值=1.2(SD=1.76)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- Brainomix自动ASPECTS评分与专家共识高度相关,可用于辅助早期缺血改变的评估。
- Frontier自动ASPECTS评分与专家共识仅低至中度相关,阅片时需谨慎对待其评分结果。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Computer-aided diagnosis (CAD) appears promising in early ischemic change detection computed tomography (CT). This study aimed to compare the performance of two new CAD systems (Frontier ASPECTS Prototype and Brainomix) with two experienced readers in selected patients with suspected acute ischemic stroke.
METHODS: Retrospectively, non-contrast brain CTs of 150 patients suspected for acute middle cerebral artery ischemia were analyzed with respect to ASPECTS first separately, than in consensus by two senior radiologists, and by use of Frontier and Brainomix. Besides the fully automatic Frontier and Brainomix readings (Frontier_1, Brainomix_1), readings adjusted for the affected brain side (known by CT angiography or clinical presentation, Frontier_2, Brainomix_2) were assessed. Statistical analysis was performed by intraclass correlation and Bland-Altman statistics.
RESULTS: The score-based ASPECTS readings of Brainomix_1, Brainomix_2, both radiologists, and the expert consensus reading correlated highly (r = 0.714 to 0.841; always p < 0.001), whereas Frontier_1 and Frontier_2 correlated only lowly or moderately with both radiologists, the expert consensus reading, and Brainomix (r = 0.471 to 0.680; always p < 0.001). Bland-Altman analysis revealed lower mean ASPECT difference and standard deviation of difference for Brainomix_2 (mean difference = -0.2; SD = 1.15) compared to Frontier_2 (mean difference = 1.2; SD = 1.76). Correlation of region-based ASPECTS reading with the expert consensus reading was moderate for Brainomix_2 (r = 0.534), but only low for Frontier_2 (r = 0283; always p < 0.001).
CONCLUSION: We found high agreement in ASPECTS rating between both radiologists, expert consensus reading, and Brainomix, but only low to moderate agreement to Frontier.
引用
- Goebel J, Stenzel E, Guberina N, et al. Automated ASPECT rating: comparison between the Frontier ASPECT Score software and the Brainomix software. Neuroradiology. 2018. PMID: 30219935. doi:10.1007/s00234-018-2098-x
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。