文献速递儿科影像技术与安全

诊断准确性研究中无依据的等效性结论:小儿放射学科学摘要中普遍存在的推断谬误

Unfounded conclusions of equivalence in diagnostic accuracy studies: a pervasive fallacy of inference in pediatric radiology scientific abstracts.
PubMed 文献 · Pediatr Radiol · 2018-08-13

该研究由两名小儿放射科医师独立评审2016年国际小儿放射学(IPR)会议的194篇科学论文摘要,发现112篇(58%)为比较研究,其中36/112(32%)在未检出统计学显著差异的情况下作出等效或相似的无依据推断;无一篇采用等效性或非劣效性设计,也无摘要说明统计效能,仅1篇将样本量小列为局限。

要点

  • 会议摘要中32%(36/112)的比较研究在无统计学显著差异时声称等效或相似,属无依据推断。
  • 无一篇摘要采用等效性或非劣效性设计,也无一篇报告统计效能。
  • 仅1篇摘要承认样本量小是未检出显著差异的局限,阅评摘要时需警惕此类推断谬误。

核心结论

  • 2016年IPR会议诊断性能比较研究中,报告不充分与无依据的等效或相似推断较为常见;未识别这些局限可能因采用未经充分验证的影像技术而带来不良后果。

研究设计与样本

  • 对2016年国际小儿放射学(IPR)会议194篇科学论文摘要的方法学与报告质量进行独立评审,由两名小儿放射科医师完成;识别所有比较研究,并对未检出统计学显著差异却在结果或结论中声称等效或相似者,评估其研究设计类型、统计效能与样本量估算的描述。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 194篇摘要中112篇(58%)为比较研究,其中36/112(32%)作出无依据的等效或相似推断。
  • 无研究采用等效性或非劣效性设计;无摘要说明研究的统计效能;仅1篇摘要承认样本量小是未检出统计学显著差异的局限。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 阅读或撰写诊断性能比较研究摘要时,需注意未检出统计学显著差异不等于等效或相似,且应核查是否说明研究设计类型、统计效能与样本量估算。

局限性

  • 仅1篇摘要承认样本量小是未检出统计学显著差异的局限,提示多数摘要未报告该局限。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

BACKGROUND: In studies of diagnostic performance that fail to detect a statistically significant difference between compared techniques, investigators often declare evidence of equivalence or similarity without having actually tested that assertion due to incorrect methodology or insufficient statistical power.

OBJECTIVE: The purpose of our investigation is to measure the prevalence of unfounded assertions of equivalence or similarity in comparison studies presented at the International Pediatric Radiology (IPR) meeting of 2016 and promote awareness of this fallacy of inference to the pediatric radiology community.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two pediatric radiologists independently reviewed the methodology and reporting quality of the 194 scientific paper abstracts from the 2016 IPR meeting. All comparison studies were identified and those failing to detect a statistically significance difference and making a claim of equivalence or similarity in the results or conclusion were assessed for a description of the study design type, statistical power and sample size estimator calculation.

RESULTS: Of 194 scientific paper abstracts, 112 (58%) were comparison studies. Of these, 36/112 (32%) made unfounded inferences of equivalence or similarity in diagnostic imaging performance. No study had an equivalence or non-inferiority design. No abstract specified the statistical power of the study, and only one abstract acknowledged a small sample size as a limitation in detecting a statistically significant difference.

CONCLUSION: Inadequate reporting and unfounded inferences of equivalence or similarity were common in diagnostic performance comparison studies presented at IPR 2016. Failure to recognize these limitations could have adverse consequences by leading to the adoption of unvalidated imaging techniques.

来源:Pediatr Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. May LA, Guillerman RP, Zhang W, et al. Unfounded conclusions of equivalence in diagnostic accuracy studies: a pervasive fallacy of inference in pediatric radiology scientific abstracts. Pediatr Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30105569. doi:10.1007/s00247-018-4222-9

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。