在人群筛查试验中,将数字乳腺断层摄影(三维乳腺摄影)与采集或合成二维乳腺摄影整合对放射科医生真阳性和假阳性检出的影响:一项描述性研究
该研究为STORM-2试验的子研究,前瞻性纳入2013-2015年意大利特伦托人群筛查的无症状≥49岁女性,比较二维乳腺摄影、整合二维/三维、合成二维及合成二维/三维四种阅片方案下7名放射科医生的检出指标。结果显示各医生真阳性检出率与假阳性召回率存在差异,但多数阅片者呈现癌症检出增加同时假阳性召回增加的整体模式。
要点
- 整合三维乳腺摄影后,各放射科医生带来的增量癌症检出率在0/1000至3.5/1000次筛查之间。
- 合成二维/三维方案下真阳性检出率中位数78%,高于合成二维的64%和二维的59.5%。
- 合成二维/三维方案假阳性召回率中位数3.0%,高于二维的2.25%。
核心结论
- 整合三维乳腺摄影对个体放射科医生真阳性和假阳性检出的效应幅度存在差异,但多数阅片者呈现癌症检出增加同时假阳性召回增加的整体模式。
研究设计与样本
- STORM-2试验的前瞻性描述性子研究,纳入2013-2015年特伦托人群筛查的无症状≥49岁女性,设平行双阅片组分别整合三维乳腺摄影与采集或合成二维乳腺摄影;由7名放射科医生完成筛查阅片,计算每位医生的检出癌症数、真阳性检出比例及假阳性召回数与召回率。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 二维乳腺摄影:真阳性检出(相对敏感度)范围46%至100%(中位数59.5%),假阳性召回率范围1.2%至2.7%(中位数2.25%)。
- 整合二维/三维乳腺摄影:真阳性检出范围75%至100%(中位数76%),假阳性召回率范围1.5%至3.4%(中位数2.75%)。
- 合成二维乳腺摄影:真阳性检出范围56%至76%(中位数64%),假阳性召回率范围1.6%至4.6%(中位数2.4%)。
- 合成二维/三维乳腺摄影:真阳性检出范围67%至88%(中位数78%),假阳性召回率范围1.8%至6.7%(中位数3.0%)。
- 整合三维乳腺摄影带来的增量癌症检出率为0/1000至3.5/1000次筛查。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
- 研究结论指出整合三维乳腺摄影对个体放射科医生真阳性和假阳性检出的效应幅度存在差异,但多数阅片者呈现癌症检出增加同时假阳性召回增加的整体模式。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: We previously reported the Screening with tomosynthesis or standard mammography-2 (STORM-2) trial, showing that tomosynthesis (3D-mammography) screening detected more cancers than 2D-mammography in double-reading practice. In this study, we report reader-specific detection measures for radiologists who performed the screen-reading in this trial.
METHODS: This is a sub-study of the STORM-2 trial which prospectively integrated 3D-mammography with acquired or synthetized 2D-mammograms in parallel double-reading arms. Asymptomatic women ≥49 years who attended population-based screening (Trento, 2013-2015) were recruited. Screening participants were recalled at any positive sequential screen-read in either reading arm of the trial. Radiologist-specific detection measures were calculated for each of seven radiologists who performed screen-reads: number of detected cancers, proportion of true-positive (TP) detection, and number and rate of false-positive (FP) recalls (FPR). We estimated incremental cancer detection rate (CDR) from integrating 3D-mammography in screen-reading.
RESULTS: Across all radiologists, TP detection (relative sensitivity) ranged between: 46% and 100% (median 59.5%) for 2D-mammography; 75% and 100% (median 76%) for integrated 2D/3D-mammography screening; 56% and 76% (median 64%) for 2Dsynthetic; 67% and 88% (median 78%) for 2Dsynthetic/3D-mammography. Integrating 3D-mammography led to incremental CDRs between 0/1000 and 3.5/1000 screens. FPR ranged between: 1.2% and 2.7% (median 2.25%) for 2D-mammography; 1.5% and 3.4% (median 2.75%) for 2D/3D-mammography; 1.6% and 4.6% (median 2.4%) for 2Dsynthetic; and 1.8% and 6.7% (median 3.0%) for 2Dsynthetic/3D-mammography.
CONCLUSIONS: There was variability in the magnitude of effect from integrating 3D-mammography (relative to screen-reading with acquired or synthesised 2D-mammography alone) on individual radiologist's TP and FP detection, although there was an overall pattern of increasing cancer detection and also increasing FP recall for most readers.
引用
- Bernardi D, Li T, Pellegrini M, et al. Effect of integrating digital breast tomosynthesis (3D-mammography) with acquired or synthetic 2D-mammography on radiologists' true-positive and false-positive detection in a population screening trial: A descriptive study. Eur J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30150047. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2018.07.008
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。