文献速递乳腺乳腺X线

数字乳腺X线摄影中独立双阅片的获益:对所有可能配对方法学的理论评估

Benefits of Independent Double Reading in Digital Mammography: A Theoretical Evaluation of All Possible Pairing Methodologies.
PubMed 文献 · Acad Radiol · 2018-07-29

研究基于16名放射科医生独立阅读的三个病例集,计算敏感度、特异度和正确比例,比较单阅片与预期双阅片性能,并理论评估所有可能配对方案(n=10,395)。结果显示双阅片较单阅片的预期性能提升在所有性能指标和病例集均显著(p ≤ .003),随机配对即可获得大部分获益,而策略性配对可能最大化双阅片获益。

要点

  • 双阅片较单阅片在所有性能指标和病例集上均有显著提升(p ≤ .003)。
  • 全部理论配对方案(n=10,395)的预期性能提升范围为.05至.08。
  • 随机配对可获得大部分双阅片获益,策略性配对可能最大化获益。

核心结论

  • 双阅片可带来显著获益,随机配对即可实现大部分双阅片获益,而策略性配对方法可能最大化双阅片的获益。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究纳入16名放射科医生独立阅读三个病例集,比较单阅片与预期双阅片性能,并理论评估所有可能配对方法学;使用Bootstrap重采样方法进行统计分析。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 双阅片较单阅片的预期性能提升(delta performance)在所有性能指标和病例集均显著(p ≤ .003);全部理论配对方案(n=10,395)的delta performance范围为.05至.08;20个最佳配对方案的delta performance显著(p < .001),范围为.07至.10;20个随机配对方案的delta performance显著(p ≤ .003),范围为.05至.08;20个最差配对方案的delta performance范围为.03至.06,其中delta正确比例在所有三个病例集均显著(p ≤ .021),delta特异度在两个病例集显著(p ≤ .033)但第三个病例集未达显著(p = .131),delta敏感度在三个病例集均未达显著(.098 ≥ p ≥ .067)。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 作者认为,随机配对可实现大部分双阅片获益,而策略性配对方法可能最大化双阅片的获益。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To establish the efficacy of pairing readers randomly and evaluate the merits of developing optimal pairing methodologies.

MATERIALS AND METHODS: Sensitivity, specificity, and proportion correct were computed for three different case sets that were independently read by 16 radiologists. Performance of radiologists as single readers was compared to expected double reading performance. We theoretically evaluated all possible pairing methodologies. Bootstrap resampling methods were used for statistical analyses.

RESULTS: Significant improvements in expected performance for double versus single reading (ie, delta performance) were shown for all performance measures and case-sets (p ≤ .003), with overall delta performance across all theoretically possible pairing schemes (n = 10,395) ranging between .05 and .08. Delta performance for the 20 best pairing schemes was significant (p < .001) and ranged between .07 and .10. Delta performance for 20 random pairing schemes was also significant (p ≤ .003) and ranged between .05 and .08. Delta performance for the 20 worst pairing schemes ranged between .03 and .06, reaching significance in delta proportion correct (p ≤ .021) for all three case-sets and in delta specificity for two case-sets (p ≤ .033) but not for a third case-set (p = .131), and not reaching significance in delta sensitivity for any of the three case-sets (.098 ≥ p ≥ .067).

CONCLUSION: Significant benefits accrue from double reading, and while random reader pairing achieves most double reading benefits, a strategic pairing approach may maximize the benefits of double reading.

来源:Acad Radiol,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Brennan PC, Ganesan A, Eckstein MP, et al. Benefits of Independent Double Reading in Digital Mammography: A Theoretical Evaluation of All Possible Pairing Methodologies. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30064917. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.06.017

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。