乳头溢液:美国放射科医师影像检查选择的差异性
该研究通过在线调查美国放射学会认证的乳腺摄影机构首席解读医师,评估其对生理性和病理性乳头溢液影像检查方式的选择。共收到849份回复(回复率10.4%),结果显示医师对生理性溢液选择差异较大,而对病理性溢液多数推荐诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声,但非学术机构及乳腺阅片占比低于50%的医师更少遵循美国放射学会推荐标准。
要点
- 生理性乳头溢液:46%推荐诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声,30%推荐筛查性乳腺摄影,24%仅推荐诊断性乳腺摄影。
- 病理性乳头溢液:91.0%推荐诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声,8.5%仅推荐诊断性乳腺摄影,不足1.0%推荐筛查性乳腺摄影。
- 非学术机构及乳腺阅片占比低于50%的医师对生理性溢液更倾向推荐诊断性乳腺摄影(伴或不伴超声),而非美国放射学会推荐的筛查性乳腺摄影。
核心结论
- 美国放射科医师在处理良性和病理性乳头溢液影像工作流程中选择的检查方式存在差异,未统一遵循美国放射学会实践指南,可能导致不必要的检查和额外医疗费用。
研究设计与样本
- 在线调查发送至美国放射学会认证的乳腺摄影机构首席解读医师,共发放8170份调查,收到849份回复,回复率10.4%;统计分析采用卡方检验和多分类逻辑回归。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 生理性乳头溢液(双侧溢液、多导管开口、黄色/绿色/白色):30%推荐筛查性乳腺摄影,24%仅推荐诊断性乳腺摄影,46%推荐诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声。
- 病理性乳头溢液(单侧溢液、单导管开口、自发性浆液性溢液、透明或血性):91.0%推荐诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声,8.5%仅推荐诊断性乳腺摄影,不足1.0%推荐筛查性乳腺摄影。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 美国放射学会推荐生理性乳头溢液采用筛查性乳腺摄影,病理性乳头溢液采用诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声。
- 非学术机构执业及乳腺阅片占比低于50%的医师对生理性溢液更倾向推荐诊断性乳腺摄影(伴或不伴超声),而非筛查性乳腺摄影。
- 乳腺阅片占比低于50%的医师在传统影像阴性后更倾向推荐MRI。
- 非学术机构执业及乳腺阅片占比低于50%的医师对病理性溢液更少推荐诊断性乳腺摄影加靶向超声,而更倾向仅推荐诊断性乳腺摄影。
局限性
- 调查回复率为10.4%(849/8170)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study was to assess radiologists' choice of imaging modality for the evaluation of clinical symptoms of physiologic nipple discharge (e.g., bilateral discharge, multiple-duct orifices, and yellow, green, or white color) and pathologic nipple discharge (e.g., unilateral discharge, single-duct orifices, spontaneous and serous discharge, and clear or bloodstained color).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: An online survey was sent to lead interpreting physicians at mammography facilities accredited by the American College of Radiology (ACR). Statistical analysis was performed using chi-square tests for frequency data and multinomial logistic regression.
RESULTS: A total of 849 responses to 8170 distributed surveys were received, for a response rate of 10.4%. For the workup of physiologic nipple discharge, 30% of respondents recommended screening mammography (SM); 24%, diagnostic mammography (DM) only; and 46%, both DM and targeted ultrasound (US) (DM plus US). For the workup of physiologic nipple discharge, practitioners in nonacademic settings and those who read breast images during less than 50% of their practice were significantly more likely to recommend DM (with or without US), compared with SM (the standard recommended by the ACR). Those reading breast images less than 50% of the time were also more likely to recommend MRI after conventional imaging revealed negative results. For the workup of pathologic nipple discharge, 91.0% of respondents recommended DM plus US; 8.5%, DM only; and fewer than 1.0%, SM. Nonacademic providers and those who read breast images less than 50% of the time were significantly less likely to recommend DM plus US (the standard recommended by the ACR), compared with DM only.
CONCLUSION: The present study shows variability in imaging modality selection among U.S. radiologists handling the imaging workflow for benign and pathologic nipple discharge. Radiologists do not uniformly follow ACR practice guidelines, which potentially leads to unnecessary workups and extra health care costs.
引用
- Patel BK, Ferraro C, Kosiorek HE, et al. Nipple Discharge: Imaging Variability Among U.S. Radiologists. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2018. PMID: 30106616. doi:10.2214/AJR.18.19622
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。