双光束双能CT与双源双能CT衍生虚拟平扫衰减值的扫描间与扫描内比较
本回顾性研究比较单源分滤双能CT(tbDECT)与双源双能CT(dsDECT)衍生虚拟平扫衰减值的可靠性与可比性。扫描间比较纳入126例在224±180天内接受两台设备扫描的患者,扫描内比较纳入90例在136±140天内接受同一设备两次扫描的患者。结果显示tbDECT与dsDECT在7个组织中有6个VUE CT值差异显著(P<0.01),个体患者超过10 HU差异的比例为15%(左肾)至62%(脾);扫描内重复扫描两者均无显著差异(P>0.05),但tbDECT有10%患者出现超过10 HU差异而dsDECT为0%。结论认为两种双能平台VUE HU测量值不能可靠地用于随访CT比较。
要点
- tbDECT与dsDECT在7个组织中有6个VUE CT值差异显著(P<0.01)。
- 个体患者两平台间超过10 HU差异的比例为15%(左肾)至62%(脾)。
- 同一设备重复扫描tbDECT有10%患者、dsDECT有0%患者出现超过10 HU差异。
核心结论
- 双能技术衍生VUE衰减值的可重复性存在差异,本研究中tbDECT的VUE HU测量变异高于dsDECT。
- 若随访CT使用这两种不同的双能CT平台,虚拟平扫HU测量值不能可靠地进行比较。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性研究,比较tbDECT与dsDECT在不同双能平台内部及平台之间的VUE衰减值。
- 扫描间比较纳入126例在224±180天内接受两台设备扫描的患者。
- 扫描内比较纳入另外90例在136±140天内接受同一设备两次扫描的患者。
- VUE图像基于静脉期序列处理获得,记录7种不同组织的衰减值。
- 两次扫描间VUE HU测量差异大于10 HU定义为不一致。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 扫描间分析显示tbDE与dsDE的VUE CT值在7个组织中的6个差异显著(P<0.01)。
- 个体患者tbDE与dsDE之间超过10 HU差异的病例比例范围为15%(左肾)至62%(脾)。
- 扫描内分析显示tbDECT和dsDECT重复扫描均无显著差异(P>0.05)。
- 扫描内VUE HU测量超过10 HU的不一致在tbDECT扫描患者中为10%,在dsDECT扫描患者中为0%。
- 超过10 HU误差比例最高的器官为肝脏和主动脉(均为20%)。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The aim of the current study was to evaluate the reliability and comparability of virtual unenhanced (VUE) attenuation values derived from scans of a single-source, dual-energy computed tomography using a split-filter (tbDECT) to a dual-source dual-energy CT (dsDECT).
MATERIALS AND METHODS: In this retrospective study, comparisons for tbDECT and dsDECT were made within and between different dual-energy platforms. For the interscanner comparison, 126 patients were scanned with both scanners within a time interval of 224 ± 180 days; for the intrascanner comparison, another 90 patients were scanned twice with the same scanner within a time interval of 136 ± 140 days. Virtual unenhanced images were processed off of venous phase series. Attenuation values of 7 different tissues were recorded. Disagreement for VUE HU measurements greater than 10 HU between 2 scans was defined as inadequate.
RESULTS: The interscanner analysis showed significant difference between tbDE and dsDE VUE CT values (P < 0.01) for 6 of 7 organs. Percentage of cases that had more than 10 HU difference between tbDE and dsDE for an individual patient ranged between 15% (left kidney) and 62% (spleen).The intrascanner analysis showed no significant difference between repeat scans for both tbDECT and dsDECT (P > 0.05). However, intrascanner disagreements for the VUE HU measurements greater than 10 HU were recorded in 10% of patients scanned on the tbDECT and 0% of patients scanned on the dsDECT. The organs with the highest portion of greater than 10 HU errors were the liver and the aorta (both 20%).
CONCLUSIONS: Dual-energy techniques vary in reproducibility of VUE attenuation values. In the current study, tbDECT demonstrated higher variation in VUE HU measurements in comparison to a dsDECT. Virtual unenhanced HU measurements cannot be reliably compared on follow-up CT, if these 2 different dual-energy CT platforms are used.
引用
- Obmann MM, Kelsch V, Cosentino A, et al. Interscanner and Intrascanner Comparison of Virtual Unenhanced Attenuation Values Derived From Twin Beam Dual-Energy and Dual-Source, Dual-Energy Computed Tomography. Invest Radiol. 2019. PMID: 30096063. doi:10.1097/RLI.0000000000000501
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。