腹部影像检查的环境影响:一项初步研究
本研究采用简化的生命周期评估方法,估算超声、CT和MRI每例腹部检查在生产与使用阶段的多因素环境影响。结果显示超声在能耗、CO2当量排放和污染物健康效应方面均低于CT和MRI,提示超声环境负担最小,可为成本效果分析和政策制定提供参考。
要点
- 超声每例腹部检查生产与使用阶段能耗分别为7.8和10.3 MJ,低于CT和MRI。
- 超声每例CO2当量排放生产0.5 kg、使用0.65 kg,低于CT和MRI。
- 超声在污染物排放所致潜在人体健康效应方面生产和使用阶段均最小。
核心结论
- 在超声、CT和MRI三种影像方式中,超声的环境影响最小,在多个领域相差一个或多个数量级。
研究设计与样本
- 采用SimaPro软件及用户手册和现场专家数据进行简化的生命周期评估,估算超声、CT和MRI每例腹部影像检查生产与使用阶段的多因素环境影响;原文未报告样本量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 超声每例腹部检查生产阶段能耗7.8 MJ、使用阶段10.3 MJ,低于CT(生产58.9 MJ、使用41.1 MJ)和MRI(生产93.2 MJ、使用216 MJ)。
- 超声每例腹部检查生产阶段CO2当量0.5 kg、使用阶段0.65 kg,低于CT(生产4.0 kg、使用2.61 kg)和MRI(生产6.0 kg、使用13.72 kg)。
- 超声在生产和使用的污染物排放所致潜在人体健康效应方面均最小。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 该分析为比较不同影像方式的环境影响提供了初步框架,可能为成本效果分析和政策制定提供有用输入。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: Clinical decision making regarding the use of imaging is appropriately centered on diagnostic efficacy and individual patient factors. However, health policy and imaging guidelines may incorporate other inputs, such as cost-effectiveness and patient preference. In the context of climate change and resource scarcity, the environmental impacts of imaging modalities including ultrasound, CT, and MRI will also become relevant. The purpose of this study was to estimate the environmental impacts of various abdominal imaging examinations.
METHODS: Using commercially available software (SimaPro) and data from user manuals and field experts, a streamlined life cycle assessment was performed to estimate multifactorial environmental impacts of the production and use of ultrasound, CT, and MRI per abdominal imaging examination.
RESULTS: Ultrasound consumed less energy in both production and use phases (7.8 and 10.3 MJ/examination, respectively) than CT (58.9 and 41.1 MJ/examination) or MRI (93.2 and 216 MJ/examination). Ultrasound emitted fewer CO2 equivalents in production and use phases (0.5 and 0.65 kg/examination) than CT (4.0 and 2.61 kg/examination) or MRI (6.0 and 13.72 kg/examination). Potential human health effects from pollutant emissions were found to be smallest with ultrasound in both production and use phases.
CONCLUSIONS: Among the three imaging modalities, ultrasound was found to have the least environmental impact, by one or more orders of magnitude in various domains. This analysis provides an initial framework for comparing environmental impacts across imaging modalities, which may provide useful inputs for cost-effectiveness analyses and policymaking.
引用
- Martin M, Mohnke A, Lewis GM, et al. Environmental Impacts of Abdominal Imaging: A Pilot Investigation. J Am Coll Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30158086. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2018.07.015
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。