CT检出的偶发性肺结节相关的下游费用
该研究纳入200例胸部CT偶发肺结节患者,从电子病历识别下游事件并按2017 Fleischner学会指南分类影像科医师建议与申请医师处理,以全国Medicare费率估算费用。每结节平均下游费用为393美元,申请医师相对影像科医师建议过度管理时费用更高,结论认为影像科医师可能需要与申请医师合作以确保指南依从性。
要点
- 每结节平均下游费用为393美元,费用随结节大小、年龄及吸烟史增加而升高。
- 申请医师相对影像科医师建议过度管理时费用为940美元,高于依从时的637美元和欠管理时的166美元。
- 申请医师相对Fleischner指南过度管理时费用为860美元,高于欠管理时的208美元和依从时的292美元。
核心结论
- 偶发肺结节的下游费用差异很大,当申请医师相对影像科医师建议和Fleischner学会指南过度管理时费用尤其高。
- 为减少过度管理带来的不必要利用和费用,影像科医师可能需要与申请医师合作,以确保适当、指南依从的随访检查。
研究设计与样本
- 队列研究,纳入200例胸部CT检出偶发肺结节的患者,从电子病历识别下游事件(胸部CT、PET/CT、门诊就诊、经皮活检和楔形切除)。
- 采用2017 Fleischner学会指南对影像科医师建议和申请医师对结节的管理进行分类,下游费用按全国Medicare费率估算并计算平均费用。
关键影像表现/征象
- 5个结节行楔形切除并诊断为恶性肿瘤,无患者出现复发或转移。
- 每诊断一例恶性肿瘤的平均费用为3090美元。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 采用2017 Fleischner学会指南对影像科医师建议和申请医师管理进行分类。
- 费用不因影像科医师是否建议随访影像而显著变化(167-397美元),也不因影像科医师相对Fleischner指南依从、欠推荐或过度推荐而显著变化(313-444美元)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 申请医师相对影像科医师建议过度管理时费用为940美元,依从时为637美元,欠管理时为166美元。
- 申请医师相对Fleischner学会指南过度管理时费用为860美元,欠管理时为208美元,依从时为292美元。
- 费用在老年患者、有吸烟史的患者和较大结节中更高。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: To explore downstream costs associated with incidental pulmonary nodules detected on CT.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The cohort comprised 200 patients with an incidental pulmonary nodule on chest CT. Downstream events (chest CT, PET/CT, office visits, percutaneous biopsy, and wedge resection) were identified from the electronic medical record. The 2017 Fleischner Society Guidelines were used to classify radiologists' recommendations and ordering physician management for the nodules. Downstream costs for nodule management were estimated from national Medicare rates, and average costs were determined.
RESULTS: Average downstream cost per nodule was $393. Costs were greater when ordering physicians over-managed relative to radiologist recommendations ($940) vs. when adherent ($637) or under-managing ($166) relative to radiologists recommendations. Costs were also greater when ordering physicians over-managed relative to Fleischner Society guidelines ($860) vs. when under-managing ($208) or adherent ($292) to guidelines. Costs did not vary significantly based on whether or not radiologists recommended follow-up imaging ($167-$397), nor whether radiologists were adherent or under- or over-recommended relative to Fleischner Society guidelines ($313-$444). Costs were also higher in older patients, patients with a smoking history, and larger nodules. Five nodules underwent wedge resection and diagnosed as malignancies. No patient demonstrated recurrence or metastasis. Average cost per diagnosed malignancy was $3090.
CONCLUSION: Downstream costs for incidental pulmonary nodules are highly variable and particularly high when ordering physicians over-manage relative to radiologist recommendations and Fleischner Society guidelines. To reduce unnecessary utilization and cost from over-management, radiologists may need to assume a greater role in partnering with ordering physicians to ensure appropriate, guideline-adherent, and follow-up testing.
引用
- Rosenkrantz AB, Xue X, Gyftopoulos S, et al. Downstream Costs Associated with Incidental Pulmonary Nodules Detected on CT. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30093215. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.07.005
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。