指南与共识心血管US

众包共识:一种评估超声心动图判读准确性的新方法

Crowdsourcing consensus: proposal of a novel method for assessing accuracy in echocardiography interpretation.
指南 / 共识 · Int J Cardiovasc Imaging · 2018-08-20

研究探索将众包「多数票」共识作为评估负荷超声心动图判读准确性的替代金标准,29名参与者在两次相隔2年的调查中独立判读14例负荷超声心动图病例并与临床判读及冠状动脉造影结果比较;共识与临床判读、参与者响应及冠状动脉造影结果之间呈良好至优秀一致性,未来需在其他实验室及硬终点中验证。

要点

  • 众包「多数票」共识在全部14例负荷超声心动图病例中均可达成。
  • 共识与临床判读的一致性在首次调查为kappa=0.57,验证调查为kappa=0.75。
  • 共识与冠状动脉造影结果的一致性为kappa=0.40。

核心结论

  • 独立共识可达成,并为负荷超声心动图判读提供合理的比较依据。
  • 未来需在其他实验室及针对硬终点开展验证工作,以检验该方法的可行性与有效性。

研究设计与样本

  • 研究类型为两次相隔2年的调查,参与者独立判读基线及运动后负荷超声心动图图像。
  • 首次调查由29名参与者独立判读14例负荷超声心动图病例,所有病例均在负荷超声心动图后3个月内接受随访冠状动脉造影。
  • 以调查参与者响应率超过60%作为达成共识的标准。
  • 比较共识与负荷超声心动图临床判读、与冠状动脉造影结果之间的一致性。

诊断标准与关键数值

  • 共识定义为调查参与者响应率超过60%时对某一决策达成一致。
  • 首次调查中临床判读与共识的一致性kappa=0.57。
  • 首次调查中调查参与者响应与共识的一致性kappa=0.68。
  • 首次调查中共识与冠状动脉造影结果的一致性kappa=0.40。
  • 验证调查中临床判读与共识的一致性kappa=0.75,调查参与者响应与共识的一致性kappa=0.81。

临床应用与阅片要点

  • 负荷超声心动图判读质量常以冠状动脉造影数据为参照,但冠状动脉造影上的解剖性阻塞性冠心病对负荷诱发室壁运动异常的判断并非理想金标准。

局限性

  • 冠状动脉造影上的解剖性阻塞性冠心病对负荷诱发室壁运动异常而言并非理想金标准。
  • 未来需在其他实验室及针对硬终点开展验证工作,以检验该方法的可行性与有效性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开

Quality in stress echocardiography interpretation is often gauged against coronary angiography (CA) data but anatomic obstructive coronary disease on CA is an imperfect gold standard for a stress induced wall motion abnormality. We examined the utility of crowd-sourcing a "majority-vote" consensus as an alternative 'gold standard' against which to evaluate the accuracy of an individual echocardiographer's interpretation of stress echocardiography studies. Participants independently interpreted baseline and post-exercise stress echocardiographic images of cases that had undergone follow up CA within 3 months of the stress echo in two surveys, 2 years apart. We examined the agreement of consensus on survey (survey participant response (> 60%) for one decision) with the stress echocardiography clinical read and with CA results. In the first survey, 29 participants reviewed and independently interpreted 14 stress echo cases. Consensus was reached in all 14 cases. There was good agreement between clinical and consensus (kappa = 0.57), survey participant response and consensus (kappa = 0.68) and consensus and CA results (kappa = 0.40). In the validation survey, the agreement between clinical reads and consensus (kappa = 0.75) and survey participant response and consensus (kappa = 0.81) remained excellent. Independent consensus is achievable and offers a fair comparison for stress echocardiographic interpretation. Future validation work, in other laboratories, and against hard outcomes, is necessary to test the feasibility and effectiveness of this approach.

来源:Int J Cardiovasc Imaging,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Minter S, Armour A, Tinnemore A, et al. Crowdsourcing consensus: proposal of a novel method for assessing accuracy in echocardiography interpretation. Int J Cardiovasc Imaging. 2018. PMID: 30128849. doi:10.1007/s10554-018-1389-y

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。