评估2016-2017年影响医学生放射科住院医师培训项目排名的因素与资源
本研究通过匿名在线调查(应答率18.8%,117/622)评估2016-2017学年申请放射科住院医师培训的医学生排名因素与信息资源;受访者认为住院医师和教职员工的幸福感、近期毕业生的 fellowship 与工作安置、与现任住院医师的互动、科室与项目的稳定性以及地理位置是最重要的因素;面试日接触的因素对申请者看法有显著影响。
要点
- 申请者最看重住院医师和教职员工的幸福感(4.69)及近期毕业生的 fellowship 与工作安置(4.34)。
- 与现任住院医师互动(4.33)和科室与项目稳定性(4.29)也位列前五重要因素。
- 项目网站作为信息来源的排名高于网络论坛和留言板。
核心结论
- 医学生在决定排名名单时考虑大量因素和资源,面试日接触的因素对申请者看法有显著影响。
研究设计与样本
- 经 IRB 批准后,向 622 名申请诊断放射科和/或介入放射科 integrated pathway 的申请者发送匿名在线 19 题调查;申请者对 35 个可能影响排名顺序的因素从 1(完全不重要)到 5(非常重要)进行评分,并列出前五「非常重要」因素,同时排列用于了解住院医师培训项目的各种信息来源;还包括一般申请者人口学问题。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 影响申请者项目排名的前 5 个最重要因素:住院医师和教职员工的幸福感(4.69)、近期毕业生的 fellowship 与工作安置(4.34)、与项目现任住院医师的互动(4.33)、科室与项目的稳定性(4.29)、项目地理位置(4.27)。
- 了解住院医师培训项目的前 5 个资源:与项目现任住院医师互动(4.47)、项目主任(3.87)、面试教职员工(3.87)。
- 项目网站作为信息来源的排名高于网络论坛和留言板。
局限性
- 应答率为 18.8%(117/622)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES: Recent changes in radiology curriculum and access to residency program information, including the introduction of various online resources and the Interventional Radiology integrated pathway, may influence the rank list order of medical student applicants. The purpose of this study is to assess factors that affect the rank lists of medical students applying to our radiology residency program in the 2016-2017 academic year.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: After IRB approval, an anonymous online 19 question survey was emailed to 622 applicants to our diagnostic radiology and/or interventional radiology integrated pathway. Applicants ranked 35 unique factors that may influence their residency rank list order from 1 (not important at all) to 5 (very important), listed their top five 'very important' factors, and ranked various sources of information used to learn about residency programs. General applicant demographic questions were also included.
RESULTS: Response rate was 18.8% (117/622). The 5 most important factors affecting applicant ranking of programs are perceived happiness of the residents and faculty (4.69), fellowship and job placement of recent graduates (4.34), interactions with programs' current residents (4.33), stability of the department and program (4.29), and geographic location of the program (4.27). The top 5 resources for learning about residency programs were interactions with current residents at the program (4.47), program director (3.87), and interviewing faculty (3.87). Individual program websites were ranked more highly than internet message boards and forums as an information source.
CONCLUSION: Medical students consider a large number of factors and resources in determining their rank lists, with factors encountered during the interview day playing a significant role in shaping the applicants' view of a residency program.
引用
- Luk L, Maher MD, Desperito E, et al. Evaluating Factors and Resources Affecting Ranking of Diagnostic Radiology Residency Programs by Medical Students in 2016-2017. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30033195. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.05.001
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。