改良Friedman技术:一种在盂肱关节发育不良中测量肩胛盂版本角的新提议方法
回顾性分析2012年1月至2017年9月30例臂丛神经产瘫患者的30个正常与发育不良肩关节MRI,4名儿科放射科医师分别用Friedman法、改良Friedman法和真实轴位重排法测量肩胛盂版本角;改良Friedman法与真实轴位重排法在正常及发育不良肩关节中均无显著差异,作者提出改良Friedman技术可替代后处理真实轴位重排法进行测量。
要点
- 在发育不良肩关节中,改良Friedman法与真实轴位重排法测量值无显著差异(P=0.06)。
- Friedman原法与真实轴位重排法在正常及发育不良肩关节中均有显著差异(P≤0.001)。
- 4名阅片者中3名的改良Friedman法与真实轴位重排法在发育不良肩关节中达到等效(P≤0.001)。
核心结论
- 在盂肱关节发育不良中,改良Friedman法与后处理真实轴位重排法提供统计学相似且可重复的肩胛盂版本角测量值,作者提出改良Friedman技术可替代后处理真实轴位重排法进行测量。
研究设计与样本
- 经机构审查委员会批准的回顾性研究,纳入2012年1月至2017年9月间30例已确诊臂丛神经产瘫患者的30个正常与发育不良肩关节MRI,由4名儿科放射科医师分别使用Friedman法、改良Friedman法和真实轴位重排法测量肩胛盂版本角,参考标准为真实轴位重排法。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 正常肩关节:Friedman法测量值-10.8±5.7° vs 真实轴位重排法-8.8±5.3°(P≤0.001,差异显著);改良Friedman法-6.3±5.8° vs 真实轴位重排法-8.8±5.3°(P=0.06,无显著差异)。发育不良肩关节:Friedman法-34.6±17.7° vs 真实轴位重排法-28.1±17.5°(P≤0.001,差异显著);改良Friedman法-29.0±18.3° vs 真实轴位重排法-28.1±17.5°(P=0.06,无显著差异)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 改良Friedman技术通过选择与肩峰-肩胛体交界相关的参考点,更好地考虑了肩胛骨位置,作者提出该技术可替代后处理真实轴位重排法进行肩胛盂版本角测量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND: Glenoid version angles are measured to objectively follow changes related to glenohumeral dysplasia in the setting of brachial plexus birth palsy. Measuring glenoid version on cross-sectional imaging was initially described by Friedman et al. in 1992. Recent literature for non-dysplastic shoulders advocates time-consuming reconstructions and reformations for an accurate assessment of glenoid version.
OBJECTIVE: To compare Friedman's original method for measuring glenoid version to a novel technique we developed ("modified Friedman") with the reference standard of true axial reformations.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: With institutional review board approval, we retrospectively examined 30 normal and dysplastic shoulders obtained from magnetic resonance imaging examinations of 30 patients with an established diagnosis of brachial plexus birth palsy between January 2012 and September 2017. Four pediatric radiologists performed glenoid version measurements using Friedman's method, the modified Friedman method and a previously described true axial reformation method. The modified Friedman technique better accounts for scapular positioning by selecting a reference point related to the acromion-scapular body interface. Inter-rater reliability and inter-method agreement were assessed using intraclass correlation, paired t-tests and mixed linear model analysis. Equivalence tests between methods were performed per reader.
RESULTS: Glenoid version measurements were significantly different when comparing Friedman's method to true axial reformations in normal (-10.8±5.7° [mean±standard deviation] vs. -8.8±5.3°; P≤0.001) and dysplastic shoulders (-34.6±17.7° vs. -28.1±17.5°; P≤0.001). Glenoid version measurements were not significantly different when comparing the modified Friedman's method to true axial reformations in normal (-6.3±5.8° vs. -8.8±5.3°; P=0.06) and dysplastic shoulders (-29.0±18.3° vs. -28.1±17.5°; P=0.06). Friedman's method was not equivalent to true axial reformations for measurements in dysplastic shoulders for all readers (P=0.68, 0.81, 0.86, 0.99); the modified Friedman method was equivalent to of true axial reformations for measurements in dysplastic shoulders for 3 of 4 readers (P≤0.001, P≤0.001, P≤0.001, P=0.10).
CONCLUSION: In glenohumeral dysplasia, the modified Friedman method and post-processed true axial reformations provide statistically similar and reproducible values. We propose that our modified Friedman technique can be performed in lieu of post-processed true axial reformations to generate glenoid version measurements.
引用
- Ditzler MG, Kan JH, Artunduaga M, et al. Modified Friedman technique: a new proposed method of measuring glenoid version in the setting of glenohumeral dysplasia. Pediatr Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29978295. doi:10.1007/s00247-018-4196-7
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。