影像二次判读的差异率及其临床影响:系统综述与Meta分析
该系统综述与Meta分析纳入29项研究、共12,676例影像二次判读,二次判读与初级判读的总体差异率为32.2%,其中主要发现差异率20.4%,18.6%的病例因二次判读改变了处理方案;在有参考标准的差异判读中,二次判读准确率为90.5%。
要点
- 二次判读与初级判读总体差异率32.2%,主要发现差异率20.4%。
- 18.6%的病例二次判读改变了临床处理方案。
- 有参考标准的差异判读中,二次判读准确率90.5%。
核心结论
- 影像二次判读常出现与初级判读不一致的结果,这些差异可改变处理方案,且在有参考标准时二次判读比初级判读更准确;该领域研究最多的是肿瘤影像。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述与Meta分析,检索EMBASE和PubMed,纳入报告放射科医生对其他机构初始判读影像进行二次判读差异率的原创研究,共29项研究、12,676例二次判读,其中19项研究专门提供肿瘤影像数据,由两名评价者提取资料并评估研究质量。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 二次判读与初级判读总体差异率32.2%,主要发现差异率20.4%,处理方案改变率18.6%,有参考标准的差异判读中二次判读准确率90.5%;按检查类型差异率:CT 28.3%、MRI 31.2%、肿瘤影像32.7%、体部影像43.8%、乳腺影像39.9%、肌肉骨骼影像34.0%、神经影像23.8%、儿科影像35.5%、创伤影像19.7%。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者认为,政策制定者在考虑二次影像判读的价值与支付时应考虑这些发现。
局限性
- 主要偏倚风险包括二次判读前是否可获得初始判读、其他临床信息和参考标准。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To conduct a meta-analysis of studies investigating discrepancy rates and clinical impact of imaging secondary interpretations and to identify factors influencing these rates.
METHODS: EMBASE and PubMed databases were searched for original research investigations reporting discrepancy rates for secondary interpretations performed by radiologists for imaging examinations initially interpreted at other institutions. Two reviewers extracted study information and assessed study quality. Meta-analysis was performed.
RESULTS: Twenty-nine studies representing a total of 12,676 imaging secondary interpretations met inclusion criteria; 19 of these studies provided data specifically for oncologic imaging examinations. Primary risks of bias included availability of initial interpretations, other clinical information, and reference standard before the secondary interpretation. The overall discrepancy rate of secondary interpretations compared with primary interpretations was 32.2%, including a 20.4% discrepancy rate for major findings. Secondary interpretations were management changing in 18.6% of cases. Among discrepant interpretations with an available reference standard, the secondary interpretation accuracy rate was 90.5%. The overall discrepancy rates by examination types were 28.3% for CT, 31.2% for MRI, 32.7% for oncologic imaging, 43.8% for body imaging, 39.9% for breast imaging, 34.0% for musculoskeletal imaging, 23.8% for neuroradiologic imaging, 35.5% for pediatric imaging, and 19.7% for trauma imaging.
CONCLUSION: Most widely studied in the context of oncology, imaging secondary interpretations commonly result in discrepant interpretations that are management changing and more accurate than initial interpretations. Policymakers should consider these findings as they consider the value of, and payment for, secondary imaging interpretations.
引用
- Rosenkrantz AB, Duszak R, Babb JS, et al. Discrepancy Rates and Clinical Impact of Imaging Secondary Interpretations: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis. J Am Coll Radiol. 2018. PMID: 30031614. doi:10.1016/j.jacr.2018.05.037
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。