3D打印模型对患者理解肾冷冻消融术的影响:一项前瞻性先导研究
这项前瞻性先导研究纳入25例对照组患者(接受标准肾冷冻消融教育:口头解释并复习相关二维影像)和25例实验组患者(在标准教育基础上加用3D打印肾冷冻消融模型)。实验组解剖题正确率均值显著高于对照组(87.2% vs 72.8%;p=0.007),但校正提供教育的医师后3D模型与患者解剖知识不再显著相关(p=0.22);实验组对模型重要性评分很高(理解肾肿瘤解剖均值9.4分、理解即将进行的手术均值9.5分,0-10分制),23例(92%)患者「绝对推荐」继续将3D模型作为患者教育工具。
要点
- 实验组解剖题正确率均值87.2% vs 对照组72.8%(p=0.007),但校正医师因素后p=0.22。
- 手术相关题正确率实验组93.6% vs 对照组89.6%(p=0.16),无显著差异。
- 23例(92%)患者「绝对推荐」继续使用3D模型作为患者教育工具。
核心结论
- 在这项小型先导研究中,3D肾冷冻消融模型未显著提高患者客观解剖与手术知识,但患者对该模型的主观价值评价很高,支持开展更大规模研究。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性先导研究,纳入25例对照组患者(接受标准肾冷冻消融教育:口头解释并复习相关二维影像)和25例实验组患者(在标准教育基础上加用3D打印肾冷冻消融模型);后续患者问卷包括5道解剖题和5道手术知识题。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 解剖题正确率均值:实验组87.2% vs 对照组72.8%(p=0.007);校正提供教育的医师后,3D模型与患者解剖知识不再显著相关(p=0.22)。
- 手术相关题正确率均值:实验组93.6% vs 对照组89.6%(p=0.16)。
- 实验组对3D模型重要性评分(0-10分制):理解肾肿瘤解剖均值9.4分,理解即将进行的手术均值9.5分。
- 23例(92%)患者「绝对推荐」继续将3D模型作为患者教育工具。
局限性
- 原文称本研究为小型先导研究(small pilot study)。
- 原文结论指出患者客观解剖与手术知识未因3D肾冷冻消融模型显著改善。
- 原文结论提出患者对模型的高主观价值支持开展更大规模研究。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
PURPOSE: To determine whether a 3D printed model improves patients' understanding of renal cryoablation and the involved anatomy.
METHODS: This prospective study included 25 control patients, who received standard of care renal cryoablation education (verbal explanation accompanied by review of relevant 2D imaging) and 25 experimental patients, who received education using a 3D printed renal cryoablation model in addition to standard of care. Subsequent patient surveys included 5 anatomy and 5 procedural knowledge questions. The experimental cohort also subjectively graded the importance of the 3D model for understanding the renal cryoablation procedure and associated anatomy.
RESULTS: Mean percent of anatomy questions answered correctly was significantly higher in the experimental cohort than that in the control group (87.2% vs. 72.8%; p = 0.007). After adjusting for the physician providing the education, however, the 3D model was no longer significantly associated with patient anatomy knowledge (p = 0.22). Mean percent of procedure-related questions answered correctly was higher in the experimental cohort (93.6%) than that in the control group (89.6%) (p = 0.16). The experimental cohort graded the importance of the 3D model for understanding their renal tumor anatomy and upcoming procedure to be very high (mean 9.4 and 9.5, respectively, on a 0-10 point scale). Twenty-three (92%) patients "definitely recommended" continued use of the 3D model as a patient educational tool.
CONCLUSIONS: Although patients' objective anatomy and procedural knowledge was not significantly improved with the 3D renal cryoablation model in this small pilot study, patients' high perceived value of the model supports investigation in a larger study.
引用
- Schmit C, Matsumoto J, Yost K, et al. Impact of a 3D printed model on patients' understanding of renal cryoablation: a prospective pilot study. Abdom Radiol (NY). 2019. PMID: 30054687. doi:10.1007/s00261-018-1710-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。