风险标准化对CT使用变异及急诊医师画像的影响
本研究回顾性分析一个医疗系统内四家急诊科的CT使用情况,基于七组按有无创伤指征划分的临床队列,用机器学习与分层逻辑回归进行风险标准化,评估其对医师画像的影响。结果显示风险标准化后各指征的变异系数由30.2–57.9降至12.3–22.3,但变异仍持续存在,且14.0–39.1%的医师被重新分类两个及以上十分位。
要点
- 风险标准化后CT使用变异系数由30.2–57.9降至12.3–22.3,但所有指征变异仍持续存在。
- 风险标准化使14.0–39.1%的医师被重新分类两个及以上十分位。
- 创伤胸部与腹部影像的医师内相关性最高,R值达0.80。
核心结论
- 风险标准化对CT使用变异和急诊医师画像有实质性影响,但标准化后变异仍持续存在。
- 作者认为管理者和支付方在未来医师影像测量中应纳入风险标准化,以确保绩效评估有效并提升急诊医疗价值。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析一个医疗系统内四家急诊科的CT使用情况。
- 主要结局为指征特异性、风险标准化的CT使用。
- 基于最常进行的CT检查有无创伤指征构建七个临床队列。
- 使用机器学习算法和分层逻辑回归模型进行风险标准化。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 七个队列中,针对特定指征开具超过25次CT的医师数为70至88名,急诊就诊次数为17,458至117,489次。
- 未调整的变异在各指征均较大,变异系数为30.2–57.9。
- 风险标准化后所有指征变异降低但仍持续存在,变异系数为12.3–22.3。
- 指征特异性模型中,风险标准化导致14.0–39.1%的医师被重新分类两个及以上十分位。
- 医师内相关性R值为0.02–0.80,创伤胸部与腹部影像之间最高。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 原文未据此给出针对日常阅片和报告的具体推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: The purpose of this study is to use detailed electronic health record data to profile the use of condition-specific, risk-standardized imaging by emergency physicians.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: CT utilization in four emergency departments in a single health care system was retrospectively analyzed. The primary outcome for analysis was indication-specific, risk-standardized CT utilization. We constructed seven clinical cohorts on the basis of the presence or absence of a traumatic indication for the most frequently performed CT studies. Risk standardization was performed using machine learning algorithms and hierarchic logistic regression models. Variation in CT utilization for each cohort was analyzed using coefficients of variation and box plots, the effect of risk standardization on physician profiling was determined using slope diagrams and kappa values, and within-physician correlation was assessed using correlation coefficients and matrices.
RESULTS: For the seven cohorts, the number of physicians ordering more than 25 CT studies for a particular indication ranged from 70 to 88, and the number of ED visits ranged from 17,458 to 117,489. The unadjusted variation was large for each indication (coefficient of variation, 30.2-57.9). Risk standardization resulted in reduced but persistent variation for all indications (coefficient of variation, 12.3-22.3). Among indication-specific models, risk standardization resulted in reclassification by two or more deciles for 14.0-39.1% of physicians. The R value for within-physician correlation varied from 0.02 to 0.80 and was highest between chest and abdominal imaging for trauma.
CONCLUSION: In this multisite study of CT utilization, risk standardization had a substantial impact on variation in CT utilization and emergency physician profiling. Administrators and payers should include risk standardization in future measures of physician imaging to ensure valid assessment of performance and achieve improvements in emergency care value.
引用
- Taylor RA, Melnick E, Fleishman W, et al. The Impact of Risk Standardization on Variation in CT Use and Emergency Physician Profiling. AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2018. PMID: 29975119. doi:10.2214/AJR.17.19188
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。