评估资源有限环境中使用的非商业超声凝胶
研究在利比里亚和美国测试了9种凝胶(包括商业凝胶、半强度商业凝胶及6种非商业配方),由2名医师超声医师在2具模型上获取肝肾间隙、心脏胸骨旁长轴和左贵要静脉图像,并对凝胶进行定量和定性评估。商业凝胶获得满分,黄原胶凝胶得分最高,热浓缩魔芋胶和冷魔芋胶凝胶显著差于商业凝胶;图像回顾未发现基于凝胶使用的图像质量显著差异。
要点
- 商业凝胶在凝胶评估中获满分,黄原胶凝胶得分次高。
- 热浓缩魔芋胶和冷魔芋胶凝胶显著差于商业凝胶。
- 图像回顾显示商业与非商业凝胶的图像质量无显著差异。
核心结论
- 图像回顾未发现商业凝胶与非商业凝胶在超声图像质量上有显著差异。
研究设计与样本
- 在利比里亚和美国测试9种凝胶(包括商业凝胶、半强度商业凝胶及6种非商业配方),由2名医师超声医师在2具模型上获取肝肾间隙、心脏胸骨旁长轴和左贵要静脉图像,评估者对凝胶身份设盲,采用重复测量方差分析和Tukey-Kramer校正的事后两两比较。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 商业凝胶在凝胶评估中获得满分。
- 与商业凝胶相比,黄原胶凝胶得分最高,其次是半强度商业凝胶。
- 热浓缩魔芋胶和冷魔芋胶凝胶被发现在凝胶评估中显著差于商业凝胶。
- 图像回顾中,基于所用凝胶的图像之间未发现显著差异。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者结论为图像回顾未发现商业与非商业凝胶在超声图像质量上有显著差异。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: Ultrasound (US) is increasingly used in settings where commercial US gel is unavailable. This study evaluated noncommercial gel recipes compared to commercial gel.
METHODS: A search for US gel formulations revealed 6 recipes. Half-strength commercial gel and a modified glucomannan recipe were also tested. Nine gels, including commercial gel, were tested in Liberia and the United States. In each session, 2 physician sonologists evaluated 9 gels on 2 models, obtaining videos from the hepatorenal space with a curvilinear transducer, the cardiac parasternal long view with a phased array transducer, and the left basilic vein with a linear transducer. The sonologists and models, who were blinded to gel identity, made independent quantitative and qualitative gel evaluations comparing the test gel to commercial gel. Two physician sonologists who were blinded to the gel identities and a US operator reviewed the images and rated their quality. An analysis of variance in repeated measures was performed to test for differences in the overall score, real-time quality, and other characteristics. Post hoc pairwise comparisons to commercial gel were performed with a Tukey-Kramer adjustment. Inter- and intra-rater reliability was calculated for the image review.
RESULTS: Commercial gel earned a perfect score. Compared to commercial gel, xanthine gum gel scored highest, followed by half-strength commercial gel. Hot concentrated glucomannan and cold glucomannan gel were found to be significantly worse than commercial gel. No significant difference was found between images based on the gel used on the image review.
CONCLUSIONS: No significant difference in image quality was found between commercial and noncommercial gels on US image review.
引用
- Vinograd AM, Fasina A, Dean AJ, et al. Evaluation of Noncommercial Ultrasound Gels for Use in Resource-Limited Settings. J Ultrasound Med. 2018. PMID: 30043460. doi:10.1002/jum.14697
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。