多延迟动脉自旋标记的脑灌注测量受延迟数目系统性偏倚影响
研究纳入87例认知健康对照者(78.7±3.8岁,49例女性),直接比较3延迟与7延迟动脉自旋标记序列估计的通过时间和脑血流量差异。7延迟序列在分水岭区估计的通过时间未校正和校正脑血流量均高于3延迟序列,且半球不对称性更低。结果支持多延迟动脉自旋标记采集参数标准化的必要性。
要点
- 7延迟序列在分水岭区估计的脑血流量高于3延迟序列。
- 3延迟序列在外周脑区估计的延迟更长,7延迟序列在脑中心区延迟更长。
- 7延迟序列的半球不对称性低于3延迟序列。
核心结论
- 多延迟动脉自旋标记序列中延迟数目较多者估计的脑血流量高于延迟数目较少者。
- 研究结果支持多延迟动脉自旋标记采集参数标准化的必要性,并提示基本参数是脑血流量定量研究的混杂因素。
研究设计与样本
- 研究纳入87例认知健康对照者,年龄78.7±3.8岁,其中女性49例。
- 直接比较3延迟与7延迟动脉自旋标记序列,评估估计的通过时间和脑血流量差异。
- 分析包括体素水平的置换检验序列间比较、序列内通过时间未校正与校正图比较,以及差异区域的平均脑血流量计算。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 分水岭区通过时间未校正脑血流量:7延迟序列27.62±12.23 mL/min/100 g vs 3延迟序列24.58±11.70 mL/min/100 g,Cohen's d=0.25。
- 分水岭区通过时间校正脑血流量:7延迟序列33.48±14.92 mL/min/100 g vs 3延迟序列30.16±14.32 mL/min/100 g,Cohen's d=0.23。
- 外周脑区估计延迟:3延迟序列1.52408±0.25236秒 vs 7延迟序列1.47755±0.24242秒,Cohen's d=0.19。
- 脑中心区估计延迟:7延迟序列1.39388±0.22056秒 vs 3延迟序列1.42565±0.21872秒,Cohen's d=0.14。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 阅片和报告脑血流量定量结果时需注意多延迟动脉自旋标记序列的延迟数目对估计值的影响。
- 原文结论支持在多延迟动脉自旋标记采集参数 standardized 的前提下解读脑血流量测量。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: Multidelay arterial spin-labeling is a promising emerging method in clinical practice. The effect of imaging parameters in multidelay arterial spin-labeling on estimated cerebral blood flow measurements remains unknown. We directly compared 3-delay versus 7-delay sequences, assessing the difference in the estimated transit time and blood flow.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: This study included 87 cognitively healthy controls (78.7 ± 3.8 years of age; 49 women). We assessed delay and transit time-uncorrected and transit time-corrected CBF maps. Data analysis included voxelwise permutation-based between-sequence comparisons of 3-delay versus 7-delay, within-sequence comparison of transit time-uncorrected versus transit time-corrected maps, and average CBF calculations in regions that have been shown to differ.
RESULTS: The 7-delay sequence estimated a higher CBF value than the 3-delay for the transit time-uncorrected and transit time-corrected maps in regions corresponding to the watershed areas (transit time-uncorrected = 27.62 ± 12.23 versus 24.58 ± 11.70 mL/min/100 g, Cohen's d = 0.25; transit time-corrected = 33.48 ± 14.92 versus 30.16 ± 14.32 mL/min/100 g, Cohen's d = 0.23). In the peripheral regions of the brain, the estimated delay was found to be longer for the 3-delay sequence (1.52408 ± 0.25236 seconds versus 1.47755 ± 0.24242 seconds, Cohen's d = 0.19), while the inverse was found in the center of the brain (1.39388 ± 0.22056 seconds versus 1.42565 ± 0.21872 seconds, Cohen's d = 0.14). Moreover, 7-delay had lower hemispheric asymmetry.
CONCLUSIONS: The results of this study support the necessity of standardizing acquisition parameters in multidelay arterial spin-labeling and identifying basic parameters as a confounding factor in CBF quantification studies. Our findings conclude that multidelay arterial spin-labeling sequences with a high number of delays estimate higher CBF values than those with a lower number of delays.
引用
- van der Thiel M, Rodriguez C, Giannakopoulos P, et al. Brain Perfusion Measurements Using Multidelay Arterial Spin-Labeling Are Systematically Biased by the Number of Delays. AJNR Am J Neuroradiol. 2018. PMID: 29976831. doi:10.3174/ajnr.A5717
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。