3 T 化学位移成像同相位与反相位序列:表征骨髓信号异常的最佳阈值、测量方法与诊断准确度
研究纳入 157 例 3 T MRI 中的 36 例组织学证实骨髓替代性病变和 22 处红骨髓,由两位骨肌放射科医生用两种 ROI 方法测量信号变化。Q-ROI 法采用 25% 信号下降阈值时,两位读者识别骨髓替代的敏感度至少 100%、特异度至少 86%。
要点
- 3 T 化学位移成像中,视觉选取反相位信号下降最少的 ROI(Q-ROI)并采用 25% 信号下降阈值,可准确识别骨髓替代性病变。
- 多算法 ROI(M-ROI)在病变顶部、中部和底部放置多个 ROI,其测得的病变信号变化接近零,诊断价值有限。
- 所有 M-ROI 和 Q-ROI 测量策略下,病变组织与红骨髓之间的信号变化均有显著差异(p < 0.0001)。
核心结论
- 对于 3 T 化学位移成像,采用 25% 阈值进行单次视觉靶向测量,可准确识别骨髓替代性病变。
研究设计与样本
- 从 157 例 MRI 的便利序列中纳入 36 例组织学证实骨髓替代性病变和 22 处红骨髓(其中 2 处组织学证实,其余至少稳定 6 个月),由两位骨肌放射科医生在 3 T 化学位移成像上采用两种 ROI 测量方法。
诊断标准与关键数值
- Q-ROI 法在 25% 信号下降阈值下,两位读者识别骨髓替代的敏感度至少 100%、特异度至少 86%;Q-ROI 获得最佳复合敏感度和特异度,最大约登指数为 0.955-1。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 作者结论认为,对于 3 T 化学位移成像,采用 25% 阈值的单次视觉靶向测量可准确识别骨髓替代性病变。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVE: To determine the threshold signal drop on 3-T chemical shift imaging (CSI), with in-phase (IP) and opposed-phase (OP) sequences, for accurately identifying bone marrow replacement with 100% sensitivity, and determine a clinically useful measurement method for deriving such a threshold.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: From a convenience series of 157 MRIs, 36 cases with histologically proven marrow-replacing lesions and 22 sites of red marrow (histologically proven (2) or with minimum 6-month stability) with 3-Tesla CSI were included. Two musculoskeletal radiologists performed two measurement methods (first: multiple algorithmic ROIs at the top, middle, and bottom of lesions (M-ROI); second: an ROI was drawn where there appeared to be the least opposed-phase signal reduction qualitatively/visually (Q-ROI)). Lesional and red marrow signal change (%,[(IP-OP)signal/IP signal]*100) was determined. Statistical analyses included Student's t test, Cohen's kappa, and receiver operator characteristic curve generation.
RESULTS: By M-ROI, lesion signal change was - 0.508% (confidence interval (CI) = - 5.537:4.521) and 1.348% (CI = - 3.541:6.311) for readers 1 and 2. By Q-ROI, lesion signal change was - 11.03% (CI = - 17.01:- 5.046) and - 5.657% (CI = - 12.36:1.048) for readers 1 and 2. For all M-ROI and Q-ROI measurement strategies, signal change between lesional tissue and red marrow was significantly different (p < 0.0001). QROI produced the best composite sensitivities and specificities with a maximized Youden index of 0.955-1. A threshold signal drop of 25% with Q-ROI produced at least 100%/86% sensitivity/specificity for both readers for identifying marrow replacement.
CONCLUSIONS: For 3-T CSI, a single visually targeted measurement using a 25% threshold is accurate for identifying marrow-replacing lesions.
引用
- Kumar NM, Ahlawat S, Fayad LM, et al. Chemical shift imaging with in-phase and opposed-phase sequences at 3 T: what is the optimal threshold, measurement method, and diagnostic accuracy for characterizing marrow signal abnormalities? Skeletal Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29936558. doi:10.1007/s00256-018-2999-0
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。