引产前评估胎儿枕位与脊柱位置的可靠性如何
前瞻性纳入136例初产妇,在决定引产后即刻及引产前至少1小时行经腹超声评估胎儿枕位与脊柱位置。两次评估间枕位不一致34例(25.0%)、脊柱位置不一致40例(29.4%);枕后位与脊柱后位在剖宫产与阴道分娩组间无显著差异;枕后位者引产至分娩间隔更长(1786±805 vs 1347±784 min;P=0.013)。作者认为引产前评估枕位与脊柱位置似乎与分娩方式不相关,临床价值有限。
要点
- 引产前两次超声评估枕位不一致率25.0%、脊柱位置不一致率29.4%,提示位置动态变化。
- 剖宫产组与阴道分娩组枕后位比例无显著差异(18.8% vs 17.1%;P=0.826)。
- 枕后位者引产至分娩间隔较非枕后位者延长(1786±805 vs 1347±784 min;P=0.013)。
核心结论
- 胎儿枕位与脊柱位置在相当比例的引产妇女中呈动态变化,其评估似乎与分娩方式不相关,引产前评估枕位与脊柱位置不太可能具有临床实用性。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性研究,纳入136例初产妇,在决定引产后即刻行经腹超声确定胎头与脊柱位置,至少1小时后、引产前再次评估;比较阴道分娩与剖宫产妇女的枕位与脊柱位置。
关键影像表现/征象
- 首次评估枕位为前位55例(40.4%)、横位52例(38.2%)、后位29例(21.3%)。
- 第二次评估枕位为前位62例(45.6%)、横位49例(36.0%)、后位25例(18.4%)。
- 首次评估脊柱位置为前位58例(42.6%)、横位42例(30.9%)、后位36例(26.5%)。
- 第二次评估脊柱位置为前位52例(38.2%)、横位50例(36.8%)、后位34例(25.0%)。
- 两次评估枕位不一致34例(25.0%),脊柱位置不一致40例(29.4%)。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 剖宫产组枕后位19例(18.8%)vs 阴道分娩组6例(17.1%),P=0.826。
- 剖宫产组脊柱后位27例(26.7%)vs 阴道分娩组7例(20%),P=0.428。
- 枕后位者引产至分娩间隔1786±805 min vs 非枕后位者1347±784 min,P=0.013。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
OBJECTIVES: To assess the reliability of fetal occiput and spine position determination in nulliparous women prior to induction of labor (IOL), and to evaluate identification of fetal occiput and spine positions prior to IOL in the prediction of labor outcome.
METHODS: A series of 136 nulliparous women were recruited prospectively, immediately after the decision to perform IOL was made. Transabdominal ultrasound was performed to determine fetal head and spine positions. After at least 1 h, and prior to IOL, fetal occiput and spine positions were reassessed. Fetal occiput and spine positions were then compared between women who underwent vaginal delivery and those who delivered by Cesarean section.
RESULTS: On the first and second assessments, respectively, fetal occiput position was anterior in 55 (40.4%) and 62 (45.6%) women, transverse in 52 (38.2%) and 49 (36.0%) women, and posterior in 29 (21.3%) and 25 (18.4%) women, while fetal spine position was anterior in 58 (42.6%) and 52 (38.2%) women, transverse in 42 (30.9%) and 50 (36.8%) women, and posterior in 36 (26.5%) and 34 (25.0%) women. Discordance between the first and second assessments of fetal occiput position was identified in 34 (25.0%) women, whereas discordance of fetal spine position was observed in 40 (29.4%) women. The incidence of fetal occiput posterior position in women undergoing Cesarean section was comparable to that in the vaginal-delivery group (19 (18.8%) vs 6 (17.1%); P = 0.826), which was similarly the case for fetal posterior spine position (27 (26.7%) vs 7 (20%); P = 0.428). Women with fetal occiput posterior position had a longer induction-to-delivery interval in comparison to those with non-occiput posterior fetal position (1786 ± 805 vs 1347 ± 784 min; P = 0.013).
CONCLUSIONS: Fetal occiput and spine positions are dynamic in a considerable proportion of women undergoing IOL, and their assessment does not seem to correlate with mode of delivery. Occiput and spine position assessment in women prior to IOL is unlikely to be clinically useful. Copyright © 2018 ISUOG. Published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd.
引用
- Kamel R, Youssef A. How reliable is fetal occiput and spine position assessment prior to induction of labor? Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol. 2019. PMID: 29947161. doi:10.1002/uog.19169
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。