在多中心试验中通过研究者培训实现影像标准的同质化应用:来自WAKE-UP研究的报告
WAKE-UP是一项在症状发作时间未知的卒中患者中、以MRI标准判断溶栓资格的随机安慰剂对照试验。研究描述了研究者影像培训及中心影像阅读委员会(CIRB)质量控制结果:来自8个欧洲国家的460名医师参加培训,436名(95%)通过;局部研究者与CIRB对急性缺血病灶存在与否及梗死范围判断的一致性高(94%,κ=0.87;93%,κ=0.87),对DWI-FLAIR不匹配标准的一致性为74%(κ=0.60),多数研究者认为该标准最难评估。
要点
- DWI-FLAIR不匹配是研究者认为最难评估的影像标准,局部与中心判读一致性为74%(κ=0.60)。
- 急性缺血病灶存在与否及梗死范围判断的局部与中心一致性均高(94%,κ=0.87;93%,κ=0.87)。
- 系统影像培训后,91%的应答研究者表示评估DWI-FLAIR不匹配的信心增加。
核心结论
- 尽管为多中心设计,WAKE-UP研究显示判读者在解读患者随机化所需各项影像标准(包括新的DWI-FLAIR不匹配标准)方面具有高度的同质性,系统影像培训增加了研究者应用影像标准的信心。
研究设计与样本
- WAKE-UP随机安慰剂对照试验的影像培训与质量控制报告,分析了前1069例筛查患者的CIRB质控结果,并对研究者进行反馈调查。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 局部研究者与CIRB对急性缺血病灶存在与否的一致性为94%(κ=0.87)。
- 局部研究者与CIRB对梗死范围判断的一致性为93%(κ=0.87)。
- 局部研究者与CIRB对DWI-FLAIR不匹配标准判断的一致性为74%(κ=0.60)。
临床应用与阅片要点
- 在卒中溶栓试验中,系统影像培训后局部研究者对急性缺血病灶及梗死范围的判读与中心阅读委员会高度一致。
- DWI-FLAIR不匹配是判读一致性相对较低且研究者认为最难评估的标准,影像培训可增加研究者评估该标准的信心。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE: WAKE-UP is a randomized, placebo-controlled trial of thrombolysis in stroke with unknown time of symptom onset using magnetic resonance imaging criteria to determine patients' eligibility. As it is a multicenter trial, homogeneous interpretation of criteria is an important contributor to the trial's success. We describe the investigator image training as well as results of the quality control done by the central image reading board (CIRB).
METHODS: Investigators at local centers were given an imaging manual and passed a software-based image training prior to being allowed to judge images in the trial. Throughout the trial, the CIRB gave feedback to recruiting centers in cases of disagreement regarding a patient's randomization. We evaluated the investigators performance in the image training and analyzed results of this quality control from the first 1069 screened patients. Additionally, we obtained feedback from investigators regarding their experiences with the trial.
RESULTS: Four-hundred-and-sixty physicians from eight European countries took part in the image training, of whom 436 (95%) successfully completed it. In the trial, agreement rates between the local investigators and members of the CIRB were high for the presence of an acute ischemic lesion (94%, κ = 0.87) as well as for the judgment of infarct extent (93%, κ = 0.87). Agreement for the criterion of DWI-FLAIR mismatch was 74%, κ = 0.60. The majority of investigators reported that the DWI-FLAIR mismatch was the hardest imaging criterion to evaluate. Ninety-one percent of investigators who responded to our survey stated that the image training specifically increased their confidence when assessing the DWI-FLAIR mismatch.
CONCLUSIONS: Despite its multicenter design, the WAKE-UP study has demonstrated a high level of homogeneity amongst raters in interpreting the various imaging criteria for patient randomization, including the novel criterion of DWI-FLAIR mismatch. Systematic image training increased the confidence of investigators in applying imaging criteria.
引用
- Galinovic I, Dicken V, Heitz J, et al. Homogeneous application of imaging criteria in a multicenter trial supported by investigator training: A report from the WAKE-UP study. Eur J Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29857856. doi:10.1016/j.ejrad.2018.05.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。