肌肉骨骼放射学专科培训申请与选拔流程:住院医师、专科培训医师与专科培训主任的认知调查
本研究通过三套问卷调查肌肉骨骼(MSK)放射学专科培训申请与选拔流程的认知,收到47名专科培训主任、73名专科培训医师和147名住院医师的回复。多数 offer 发生在 R3 年7月至9月,但19%的主任在 R2 年即发出 offer;72%的主任认为「来自其他项目的压力」是主要驱动因素,65%认为时间线「太早」。55%的主任、57%的专科培训医师和61.9%的住院医师支持正式匹配制度,主要理由是「公平」。
要点
- 多数 MSK 专科培训 offer 发生于 R3 年7月至9月,但19%的主任在 R2 年即发出 offer。
- 72%的主任认为「来自其他项目的压力」是制定时间线政策的主要驱动因素,65%认为时间线「太早」。
- 55%的主任、57%的专科培训医师和61.9%的住院医师支持正式匹配制度,主要理由是「公平」。
核心结论
- MSK 放射学专科培训选拔最早在 R2 年即发生,早于许多住院医师充分接触不同亚专科;各项目因应其他项目的行动而提前时间线,形成「军备竞赛」,推测是为避免错过最佳候选人;多数受访者支持正式匹配以提高公平性,但并非普遍同意这是最佳方案。
研究设计与样本
- 任务组构建三套问卷,分别针对 MSK 专科培训主任、专科培训医师和住院医师,调查当前与「理想」的申请和选拔流程;问卷分发给 MSK 专科培训主任并请其转交当前专科培训医师,同时请美国和加拿大放射学住院医师项目主任分发给当前 R3 和 R4 住院医师;对回复进行汇总分析。
诊断标准与关键数值
- 专科培训主任和专科培训医师报告多数 offer 发生在 R3 年7月至9月,但19%的主任在 R2 年即发出 offer。
- 43名主任受访者中31名(72%)认为「来自其他项目的压力」是其主要政策驱动因素,28名(65%)认为其时间线「太早」。
- 支持正式匹配的比例为:专科培训主任55%、专科培训医师57%、住院医师61.9%,主要理由是「公平」。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
英文原文(摘要)· 点击展开
RATIONAL AND OBJECTIVES: This study aimed to assess resident, fellow, and fellowship director perceptions of the musculoskeletal (MSK) radiology fellowship application process.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: A task group constructed three surveys with questions about current and "ideal" fellowship application and selection processes. Surveys were distributed to MSK fellowship directors, who were also asked to give separate surveys to current fellows. US and Canadian radiology residency directors were asked to distribute surveys to current R3 and R4 residents. Responses were tabulated and analyzed.
RESULTS: Responses were received from 47 MSK fellowship directors, 73 MSK fellows, and 147 residents. Fellowship directors and fellows reported that most fellowship offers occur between July and September of the R3 year, although 19% of directors made offers as early as the R2 year. Of the 43 director respondents, 31 (72%) noted "pressure from other programs" as the main driving force behind their policies, but 28 (65%) felt that their timelines were "too early." A formal match was supported by 55% of responding fellowship directors, 57% of fellows, and 61.9% of residents, citing "fairness" as a major justification.
CONCLUSIONS: MSK radiology fellowship selection occurs as early as the R2 year, before many residents have had substantial exposure to different subspecialties. An "arms race" has developed with programs moving their timelines earlier in response to the actions of other programs, presumably to avoid missing the best candidates. Although a majority of respondents would support a formalized match to increase fairness, there is not universal agreement that it would be the best approach.
引用
- Demertzis JL, Baker JC, Friedman MV, et al. Musculoskeletal Radiology Fellowship Application and Selection Process: Perceptions of Residents, Fellows, and Fellowship Directors. Acad Radiol. 2018. PMID: 29631928. doi:10.1016/j.acra.2018.03.011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。